1

Is 'working' a gerund in the following sentences?

My mobile was not working

He is working hard to pass the examination

  • 3
    Neither. The one in He is working ... is a verb; the one in My mobile wasn't working can be think of as a verb (it's similar to It works) or an adjective (It's working, so we can use it.) A gerund is the -ing form of a verb that functions as a noun. One good test to check if it's a gerund is to add a possessive adjective (my, your, our, their, etc.) in front of it. For example, His running is strong makes sense, so this running is a gerund. *He is my working hard to pass the examination doesn't make sense (so, not a gerund). – Damkerng T. Mar 31 '15 at 19:35
  • First of all in sentence 1 you have Past continuous (was not working) and in 2 Present continuous. Whether "working" is a gerund or a participle is debatable. The traditional view of grammars is participle. – rogermue May 31 '15 at 10:18
2

When the verb has the force of a noun it is called gerund.

In both of the sentences 'working' is used as a verb (in continuous tense).

Consider:

  1. a. Working makes me tired. - Gerund

    b. He is working in the field. - verb

  2. a. Working hard for the examination fetched him good grades. - Gerund

    b. He is working hard for the examination. - verb

In the above sentences (a) 'working' has the force of a noun and it functions as a noun, so it is gerund. While in the sentences (b) 'working' is used as a verb.

0

"was not working" is past tense continuous/progressive form. It consists of a form of to be and a verb form with the ending -ing. Today grammars say it is a present participle, but if you said it is a gerund (without preposition) it would be just as well.

You can say "I'm working" is "am + present participle" or it is "am + (in the act of) working" or "am (at/on) working". Then it would be a gerund.

Sometimes I write: to be + gp (gerund or participle, whatever you like).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.