2

I believe that movies have caused or created a false perception about a certain group of people. Instead, I believe that this group of people is exactly the opposite of how movies show them to be. I want to express this in words, in a way something like this:

As opposed to what movies have shown them to be, this group of people is very helpful and considerate.

Is the expression in bold correct? Is there a more natural way of saying it?

  • 2
    I would prefer e.g. "depict" instead of "show", because "show" can also mean "prove", but you are talking about works of fiction and not about documentary films, are you? – Stephen Apr 18 '13 at 19:14
  • This is perfectly understandable and allowable. Stephen's "depicted" would be an improvement, but it's fine as is. Jonathan Garber's suggestion of "in contrast to" is also acceptable, but I see nothing wrong with your sentence. – WendiKidd Apr 18 '13 at 21:42
1

It's usually better not to begin a sentence with "in opposition to. . ." or "as opposed to. . ." These are joining phrases, not ones to open a sentence, and they are more often used in weighing choices. A more standard way of conveying your meaning would be use of the word "contrast":

In contrast to the way some movies depict them, [Group] has [Characteristic].

If you specifically wanted to use a form of "oppose" in the sentence, you could construct it like this:

[Group] actually has [Characteristic X], as opposed to the movie depiction of them having [Characteristic Y].

Forms of "oppose" are more often used to indicate trade-offs in choices, however, not to illustrate a perceived difference in reality. A standard use might be like this:

[Option X] will cost us [N Resources], as opposed to [Option Y], which will cost us [M Resources].

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.