English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
How to say past imagination in English language?
Please explain to me whether the examples below are correct.
I want to say to my friend that he speaks English very well because he was trained by a good teacher.
“He was trained by good teacher” I want to say this as imagination/Hypothesis.
How would I say this?
“Your English is good because your Teacher would have been good in English.”
Or
“Your English is good because your Teacher would have taught you good English.”
Or
Anything else?
If you want to say that possibly something happened in the past, you can use the following forms:
Might have or could have.
However, if you realise something certainly happened in the past, you can use the form "must have".
You might have been taught by a good teacher (perhaps a good teacher taught you).
You could have been trained/taught by a good teacher (It's possible a good teacher trained/taught you).
You must have been taught by a good teacher (I realize you have certainly been taught by a good teacher).
If you are talking about an imaginary event that "happened' in the past:
Your English would be very good because you would have been taught by a good teacher.
On the other hand, you do not have to use would or any other special word. You can talk about an imaginary event using the simple past:
Your English is very good because you were taught by a very good teacher.
Just like:
Alice fell down the rabbit hole because she got too close to it.
"Would have" doesn't really work here. "Would have" simply doesn't mean "this might be the cause". It can be used to indicate an expected RESULT of something that never happened, but not a cause. Like, "You would have learned good English if you had a more experienced teacher."
The most natural way to express the idea you want is to use words like "maybe" or "perhaps" to indicate uncertainty, and a word like "because" to indicate cause. I would likely say, "Perhaps your English is good because you had a good teacher." Another possibility is, "A good teacher may be what led to your good English."
