7

I did a search for there is no any on Google (books, Ngrams). So I think the wording there is no any is grammatical. But I can't see a difference, if any, between two phrases indicated in the title. Are they interchangeable? Is the any redundant here?

There is no any case study based on this.

There is no case study based on this

  • 3
    That is an extremely miniscule percentage and it's likely that there's punctuation making it "ok" or there's a typo (There is not any")... "there is no any" used in your example is completely and utterly wrong. – Catija May 14 '15 at 21:50
  • @Catija what is the punctuation that makes it ok? The comma between no and any? – PaintTheWallsRed May 14 '15 at 21:55
  • It would be extremely contrived even if it's possible... Something like There is no "any way you like" option. – Catija May 14 '15 at 21:57
  • @PaintTheWallsRed: Something like "There is. No, any denials are incorrect." It would have to be pretty strange and unrelated. – Nathan Tuggy May 14 '15 at 21:59
  • +1 for research and showing us your thought process so far, even though it turns out the data doesn't support your conclusion when examined more closely. – snailcar May 14 '15 at 22:20
6

Short Answer

"There is no any case study based on this" is ungrammatical in standard English.

"There is no case study based on this" is fine.

"There is not any case study based on this" means "There is no case study of any kind based on this."

The two grammatical phrases are not interchangeable.

On Page 1 of your Google Book search, only two of the ten search results (Numbers 1 and 4) are unqualified examples of grammatical usage.


Details

The very first return on the google book search that you did demonstrates that this exact construction there is no any is ungrammatical in standard English.

It is an example from the book The teacher's grammar of English, and the context is talking about grammatical errors that leaners make.

The errors shown in (44) were found in a review by a Korean graduate student. The student clearly is having difficulty producing negative sentences with nonreferential there.

[44] c *Nevertheless, there is no any vocabulary or idiom lists, and no any grammatical explanation or excerises.

(44c) is an example of an error. Note that it is traditional to put an asterisk (*) before an ungrammatical sentence in books about English grammar or usage, as the book has done.


Now let's look at the Google Book search that gives the example you ask about. It just happens to demonstrate, four times, the exact error mentioned in the textbook above.

enter image description here

This return is by highly educated Victor I Chang in the $225 book Delivery and Adoption of Cloud Computing Services in Contemporary Organizations. He has a Faculty homepage at University of Southampton and a penchant for writing in the Royal We.

On this page (96) there are four uses of There is no any... They are all ungrammatical from the point of view of standard English.

For example:

The proposed method is a conceptual idea. It offers a generic recommendation. There is no any case study or demonstration based on this.

This is ungrammatical from the point of view of standard English.

By contrast, the most natural and grammatical way to say this is

The proposed method is a conceptual idea. It offers a generic recommendation. There is no case study or demonstration based on this.

or in the plural

The proposed method is a conceptual idea. It offers a generic recommendation. There are no case studies or demonstrations based on this.

If you want to use "not any," it would work more naturally in the plural:

There are not any case studies...

You can also say

There is not any case study or demonstration based on this.

"There is not any case study" means "There is no case study of any kind."

The "there is not any" construction gets plenty of use.

Note: On Page 174 of their work, Mr Chang also writes, ungrammatically: "There is no much difference whether it has been accessed using a mobile device or a standalone computer" (sic). And they have other grammatical errors in the parts of the book I checked.


Besides the result from The teacher's grammar of English, only Return 4 is definitely grammatical. In two results (Returns 3, 7) on the first page of the Google Book search

there are no any...

appears in a mathematical or scientific or logic formula. I am not a mathematician or a scientist or a logician, and I do not write formulas (formulae). Therefore I don't know if this is considered "grammatical" to the worldwide members of the scientific/mathematical community. It does not seem grammatical to me.

In regular writing, even in scientific journals and technical reports, the phrase is ungrammatical (again: from the point of view of standard English).

Other returns from the first page of the search show ungrammatical/nonstandard uses (Returns 5, 9, 10) or misprints of various sorts (Return 6, 8).


The third return is the first example appearing in a formula. It comes from Proceedings of the Sixth Asian Logic Conference: Beijing, China, 20-24 May 1996 in a chapter called "Default Logic and it's Variants: A Semantical View," by M. Zhang.

Notice that there is an error in the chapter's title (it's should be its), so I am not sure how much we can trust this author to demonstrate standard usage.

There is no any subset D' of D such that...

Logicians might consider it acceptable usage in such a formula. To me, it is not grammatical, for the same reason it is not grammatical in any English.


Compare this to the fourth return (Outline of a Phenomenology of Right):

there is no "any given" individual member

which is grammatical. Because "any given" is in quotes, the phrase is not "there is no any." This usage is similar to:

There is no "any given Sunday" on which I watch American football.

Note: "any given Sunday" is a U.S. idiom about American football.


The fifth return (Handbook of the Sociology of Health, Illness, and Healing: A Blueprint for ...) is absolutely ungrammatical and contains another nonstandard usage (get recovered from):

Since there is no any treatment that one can receive and get recovered from AIDS, then it is better to use the condoms which can protect our lives for some days before death.

On further inspection, one can see that the whole section (the four paragraphs) contains very many errors, from the point of view of standard grammar.


The summary of Return 6 (London Medical and Surgical Journal, Том 2) is a misprint. When you click on the return link, you get

If there is not any pain or inflammation...


Return 7 is a usage in a mathematical formula (Scientia Magna, International Book Series, Vol. 3, No. 1) in a chapter written by Q. Wu:

Conjecture: There is no any positive integer n...

See comments about Return 3.


Return 8 (A Complete Collection Of State-Trials And Proceedings For High ..., Том 4) shows that the scan of Page 584 has been cut off vertically along the right side. So what looks like

..., but there is no

followed by

any

starting a new line is not how the text actually reads.


In Return 9, Modern Bamboo Structures: Proceedings of the First International Conference by Yan Xiao, ‎Masafumi Inoue, ‎Shyam K. Paudel

In Japan, nearly all the bamboo forests are not maintained any longer...Especially since there is no any longer a large demand for bamboo material...

is especially ungrammatical.


Return 10 (I am not intelligent) contains very many errors from the point of view of standard English, including

Ir's just because there is no any obvious enemy in front of him to fight back.

Other nonstandard usages in this paragraph alone include:

a. The subject will find out what he face are the invisible enemies.
b. If the subject can't do that it's the another way to drive people mad.

You can find out more about I am Not Intelligent at the publisher's website. It appears to be about mental illness and schizophrenia in India, so this might explain the nonstandard English.


to sum

There is no any

is ungrammatical in the standard Englishes of the USA, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand, the Philippines, and other places that accept such English(es) as standard. This is shown in the very first return, a book about teaching English (and a very good one, I might add, that I have consulted many times--and I recommend it to the advanced learner).

There is not any case study

means "There is no case study of any kind."

It is similar to, but not always interchangeable with

There is no case study

Two returns (3 and 7) use "there is no any" in a formula, and I do not speak the English of scientific formulae. It would be considered ungrammatical outside of a formula.

Finally: A great number of the results on Pages 2 and 3 of your search are ungrammatical and are written by authors whose background seems not to be that of a native speaker of the Englishes I know about. Many of these may be (native) speakers of Indian English, and I do not know what is standard in that variety of English.

  • I'm not actually sure that it's "correct" in scientific or mathematical use... How do you know that these examples aren't similarly errors? I think they are more likely supposed to read "There is not any". – Catija May 15 '15 at 2:46
  • 2
    @Catija You may well be right. I will add extra emphasis to (You could ask at the Mathematics Stack Exchange to verify this.) Meanwhile, after Page 1, there are many many uses of "there are no any" by Indian authors. Which leads me to believe it's one of those "Indian English" things that I refuse to get involved with. – user6951 May 15 '15 at 3:01
  • Woooow, such a nice answer! – PaintTheWallsRed May 15 '15 at 6:10
  • If you have any questions, don't hesitate to ask. – user6951 May 15 '15 at 6:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.