4

In the sentence below, why is "my friends" set off with a comma?

“It is a great misfortune to be alone, my friends; and it must be believed that solitude can quickly destroy reason.”
― Jules Verne, The Mysterious Island

How do you explain this grammatically?

  • 3
    It's called "direct address" and it requires a comma. – Catija May 17 '15 at 2:56
9

It's called the vocative comma. When you address your listener or reader by name or by a description, written English grammar requires that you set off the noun or noun phrase by which you name your audience with commas. It appears in your example sentence because the speaker is directly addressing his friends.

For example, this sentence does not directly address Fred:

I saw Fred steal my roses.

The next sentence addresses Fred. It's how you'd say the same thing if you were talking to Fred:

Fred, I saw you steal my roses.

Here are some common sentences that require the vocative comma when written:

Nice job, Fred!

Ladies and gentlemen, … (at the beginning of a speech)

Dear Fred, … (at the beginning of a letter)

Gentlemen, start your engines. (Just before the beginning of an auto race.)

I can only say in my defense, your honor, that the roses were grown from seeds that the plaintiff had stolen from me. (Addressing the judge during a trial.)

Some background

It's called "vocative" by analogy with the "vocative case". In some languages, you use an altered form of a person's name when addressing them directly. For example, in Latin, when you address Quintus directly, you call him Quinte; when you address Julius, you call him Julī; and in Catholicism, when you address Dominus ("the lord") in prayers and hymns, you call him Domine.

English doesn't have a vocative case, but it does use special intonation for direct address, which almost amounts to the same thing. At the start of a sentence, you normally say a vocative phrase in a higher pitch than what follows; in the middle or at the end of a sentence, you normally say a vocative phrase in a lower pitch than the surrounding or preceding words. The comma in writing suggests this change of intonation as well as the slight pause or extended final syllable that also usually occurs in a vocative phrase.

The word "vocative" itself comes from the Latin word for "call", because it's how you call to someone. The same root appears in "vocation" (a calling), "vocabulary" (what you call stuff), and "convocation" (a meeting where many people are called together).

  • +1 But since Vatican II there aren't many lay Catholics left in the US who use Latin. – StoneyB May 17 '15 at 12:14
  • @StoneyB Indeed there aren't, and even before Vatican II, I think most lay Catholics knew almost no Latin. However, a church-organist friend keeps asking me for help with the Latin in the hymns they're singing, Latin sacred music is still sung quite a bit in concert halls, and not long ago ELU had this question about the Latin vocative in English. It doesn't really matter, though; any other language with a vocative case would also make a good illustration (or a better illustration, since Latin only has a distinct vocative case in the 2nd declension). – Ben Kovitz May 17 '15 at 12:39
  • @Ben Kovitz: English grammar requires that you set off the noun or noun phrase by which you name your audience with commas... To be precise, in spoken English the vocative phrase is separated from the rest of the clause with syntactic pauses; in writing, these pauses are conventionally represented by commas. – Tᴚoɯɐuo May 17 '15 at 13:53
  • Note that in rapid speech, the pauses optionally disappear. (In these cases, we might reasonably say the pauses were never there to begin with!) We can consider the commas structural, as in many other cases where they were originally related to pauses but can no longer be reliably associated with them. – snailcar May 17 '15 at 14:20
  • We use other terms similarly to vocative. For example, we say dative in reference to PPs headed by to, though Present-Day English clearly has no morphological dative case. – snailcar May 17 '15 at 14:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.