4

The sky is overcast so there is no sunshine, and you want to ask someone if they could feel sunshine which isn't present. Do I still need to add "the" with sunshine?

  1. Can you feel sunshine?
  2. Can you feel the sunshine?
  • Not sure what you mean. One can feel the warmth of the sun, but sunshine refers to its light. The fact that "it isn't present" makes your question doubly difficult to understand. – Tᴚoɯɐuo May 25 '15 at 17:17
  • 1
    If I heard someone say "Can you feel the sunshine?" I would hear it as "Can you feel the sun shine?", referring to the immediate here-and-now. If I heard "Can you feel sunshine?" I would take it to mean, "In general, does the light of the sun create a perceptible sensation (defined as 'feeling')?" In your specific example I think either way works because the general case would seem very unusual and the overcast skies provide more context in which the question makes sense. "Can you feel sunshine" would, I think, imply that you, yourself, do not feel any. Adding "the" sounds like you do. – Darren Ringer May 25 '15 at 21:30
  • I got sunshine on a cloudy day. – user6951 May 26 '15 at 5:17
  • We would ask, Do you feel any warmth from the sun?. We use "the" because we know our one and only sun to be still there even when we cannot see it. But I doubt we would ask "Can you feel any sunshine?" – Tᴚoɯɐuo May 26 '15 at 12:57
8

In the context of your question, the first choice is probably better. Your first sentence, without "the", implies that the speaker may or may not feel sunshine, and is in a sense asking for confirmation. The second sentence, with "the" implies that the speak does feel the sunshine, and is asking if the other person can feel it as well.

Compare to:

"Can you hear bells?" - I think I might hear bells, but it could be a ringing in my ears.

"Can you hear the bells?" - I can hear the bells and want to know if you do too.

  • Is this a good example? In your first sentence, the implication is that you don't know which bells you might be hearing. With sunshine, there is no such doubt. – Mr Lister May 25 '15 at 18:14
0

Once when I was a child, there were tornadoes in our area, and we were in our basement. At some point, the sun came out, and I said that I saw sunshine. Not the sunshine, but sunshine; the sunshine that was shining through our basement window.

Leaving out the implies a quantity of sunshine, sunshine as applied in some context. Some sunshine, in other words. Consider these three sentences:

Sunshine is the best source of Vitamin D.
To get Vitamin D, go out and get some sunshine.
To get Vitamin D, go out in the sunshine.

The first two imply that sunshine is a quantifiable resource, whereas the last one references all sunshine.

An analogous concept is the sky. As a child, I was afraid of thunderstorms. If the clouds got dark, I would look for a patch of blue sky. If I found one, I would say that there wasn't going to be a thunderstorm, because I could "see blue sky."

0

It's difficult to imagine someone asking your questions naturally without the help of clarifying body language or tone. To avoid confusion, you could ask:

  1. Do you feel any sunshine?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.