1

My scarf falls off on you.

Does the sentence make sense when we use "falls off on"? Could "on" go after "fall off"?

Or, can we avoid the "on" totally and still have a sentence that makes sense? like:

My scarf falls off you.

1

This is to fall off + a prepositional phrase (in this case the preposition is on)

To your example:

My scarf fall off on you.

With a singular subject it needs to be falls off on.

In your example, it seems like you referring to a past occurrence, so I would use:

My scarf fell off on you.

A more sensible use of falls off on might be:

If my ring is too loose it falls off on the table.

In your second example, it is different when you write:

My scarf fell off you.

You substituted the prepositional phrase on you with a direct object (you), so the meaning changes.

This phrase is saying that "you" had the scarf on, and it fell off. But it does not say where it went.

0

This should be a comment, but I don't have the rep on this site to comment. I am trying to visualize the situation. Who is wearing the scarf? If the speaker is wearing the scarf, is she bending over the other person? If so, say: "My scarf fell on you", or, if it is happening as you speak: "My scarf is falling on you." If the other person is wearing your scarf, the Answer above, which says "My scarf fell off you" works, or, if it is happening as you speak, "My scarf is falling off you." You would not say "My scarf fall....." as "scarf" is singular and takes the singular "falls".
"My scarf falls onto you" is technically OK, but sounds odd, sort of pseudo-literary.

0

Yes, you can say

  • My scarf {falls/fell} off on you.

That means that I {am/was} wearing it, then it {falls/fell} off of me and onto you.

But if you change it to

  • My scarf {falls/fell} off you.

It means "You {are/were} wearing my scarf, then it {falls/fell} off of you." (Where it goes/went, we know not.)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.