2

Dictionary says 'lay over' means 'a short stop in a journey', 'stopover', but I don't understand this sentence translating 'lay over' as 'stopover'.

Here is the sentence, which is from 'Baker's blue-jay yarn' by Mark Twain:

And there's yet another thing; in the one little particular of scolding - just good, clean, out-and-out scolding - a blue-jay can lay over anything, human or divine. Yes, sir, a jay is everything that a man is.

  • 1
    Damkeng found it. So, to put it shortly, in regard to this question and your question about scolding: A bluejay is better at scolding than anyone else. – Brian Hitchcock Aug 2 '15 at 7:18
  • @BrianHitchcock Actually, snailboat was the one who found it in OED. My hat off to snailboat. ;-) – Damkerng T. Aug 2 '15 at 8:05
4

'Lay over' = to excel, to 'put in the shade'

This sense of lay over is uncommon, as far as I can tell. Oxford English Dictionary (OED) even quotes Mark Twain in the definition of this sense of lay over! It means to excel or to 'put in the shade'.

It's defined in sense c. of 57. Lay over under Lay in the first edition of OED (1908):

c. ? U.S. colloq. To excel, to 'put in the shade'. 1869 B. HARTE Luck Roaring Camp (1870) 15 They've a street up there in 'Roaring' that would lay over any street in Red Dog. 1876 MARK TWAIN Tramp Abbr. (1880) 1. ii. 19 In scolding .. a blue-jay can lay over anything, human or divine.

(see the image below)


The definition of 'lay over', sense 57c of 'Lay' in OED


Reading comprehension

So, how can we understand our sentence in question?

First of all, I've never read this short story (What Stumped the Bluejays) by Mark Twain before, and I guessed the meaning of lay over wrong at first. Luckily, I found the text here. So, I think it's worth to discuss the text a little, enough that we can understand the sentence in the context.

Here is the introduction of the short story. The writer points out that a jay (a bluejay bird) is very good at language:

Animals talk to each other, of course. There can be no question about that; ...
[...]
There's more to a bluejay than any other creature. He has got more moods, and more different kinds of feelings than other creatures; and mind you, whatever a bluejay feels, he can put into language. And no mere commonplace language, either, but rattling, out-and-out book talk - and bristling with metaphor, too - just bristling! ...

Soon, the writer convinces us that a bluejay (or a jay) is not only as good as a human; a blue jay is really good at swearing! (Perhaps because a bluejay has lots of bristles (when bristle is a noun, it means "a short stiff hair"--because he's got feathers on him, according to the story) which makes him "bristling" (bristle the verb can either refer to the bristling of animal's fur and feathers or mean to be angry of offended about something) -- a great wordplay, IMHO.)

You may call a jay a bird. Well, so he is, in a measure - because he's got feathers on him, and don't belong to no church, perhaps; but otherwise he is just as much a human as you be. And I'll tell you for why. A jay's gifts, and instincts, and feelings, and interests, cover the whole ground. [...] Now, on top of all this, there's another thing; a jay can outswear any gentleman in the mines.

Now we reach the sentence in our question:

And there's yet another thing; in the one little particular of scolding - just good, clean, out-and-out scolding - a bluejay can lay over anything, human or divine.

So, a bluejay is not just good at swearing; he's really good at scolding. (Scolding means "to criticize someone, especially a child, severely and usually angrily for something they have done wrong".) A bluejay can lay over anything or anyone. He's really good at scolding. He excels at it! He can put everyone else's scolding in the shade. In other words, bluejays are champions of scolding!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.