4

Given arms and hands, a computer can do more varied physical work.

Is the word "given" in the sentence, the past participle or the preposition? Thanks a lot.

2

Given arms and hands, a computer can do more varied physical work.

That given in the quoted sentence is a past participle of verb.

Here given arms and hands is predicated upon the following noun phrase (NP) - a computer.

And so given here is nothing but a past participle of a verb.

2

I would tend to see "given arms and hands" as a shortened if-clause with drop of "if". Subordinate clauses can be shortened by means of participle constructions.

To my surprise I find it is not easy to show that "given" is no preposition. Perhaps someone has an idea to solve this problem. Normally a connection of preposition + noun has not the sense of a when/if-clause.

Added: The full subclause would be: "If a computer is given arms and hands ... "

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.