2

Choose the correct option:

They are building an institute next to our school.

  1. An institute next to our school is being built by them.
  2. An institute is being built by them next to our school.

In the active form of the sentence an institute is the object. So as per rule object+is+being+third form of verb+by+subject both the above mentioned passive form sentences seems to be correct. But first sentence is given as correct. Why and by what rule?

  • @VictorBazarov my aplogies. Rectified the question – Seema Bhukar Sep 19 '15 at 13:02
1

This exercise is not as it stands a very good example, because the active sentence is ambiguous; but the point behind it is important.

The people who composed this exercise have some reason to think of the preposition phrase as a modifier of the object. From what you have provided we have no way of knowing why they think that, but it may be apparent in the larger context.

The first example is presumably preferred because it keeps the preposition phrase next to our school in its original position after institute, where it may be understood as a predicate complement locating institute. In the second example the preposition phrase is separated from institute and now tells where the institute is being built: it modifies verb.

In this particular case, of course, it makes no significant difference: the institute ends up in the same place either way! But consider this sentence:

They are tearing down the school for the deaf.

If you passivize this following the first example, you have:

The school for the deaf is being torn down by them.

That's presumably what the original active sentence means. But if you passivize it following the second example you get something quite different:

The school is being torn down by them for the deaf.

That says that tearing the school down is intended to benefit the deaf, which seems very unlikely.

The lesson to be taken from this is that when you passivize and move pieces into new roles and new positions, you must be careful to keep all the pieces in their proper places.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.