6

It was ... salted the earth around your flower deck.

I wrote the second form "It was me". I have chosen the most "appropriate" answer to this question as somebody who is learning English. This decision was made on a phonetic basis so it's for sure I made a mistake.

Surely you have a rational explanation to this exercise, maybe a grammar rule, or is it an English expression?

  • 4
    Don't forget who or that. "I salted the earth around your flower deck" clefts into "It is/was [I/me] who/that [salted the earth around your flower deck]." – snailboat Sep 25 '15 at 0:05
  • What do you mean by: >It is/was [I/me] who/that "It is" goes with "I" that goes with who ? On the other hand we have "It was" which is linked to "me" and "That"? – jr28 Sep 25 '15 at 22:37
  • 1
    No, they're three independent variables. – snailboat Sep 26 '15 at 0:19
  • It was XKCD that had an amusing take on this. – J.R. Feb 15 at 22:41
10

Pick one:

  • It was I who salted the earth around your flower deck. -- (if you want to sound formal)
  • It was me that/who salted the earth around your flower deck. -- (which sounds less formal)

Both are correct, but because it's a test/question in a grammar book, and grammar books usually prefer the formal alternative, I think it wants this as the answer: It was I who ...

Note that the part "salted the earth around your flower deck" flows better with the formal alternative. A typical informal cleft-sentence of that sentence would be something like: "It was me who was responsible". (But It was me that/who salted the earth around your flower deck" is by no means wrong or incorrect.)


Reference:

From Practical English Usage by Michael Swan:

131 cleft sentences (2): it was my secretary who ...
2 It is I who ... ; It is me that ...

When an emphasised subject is a pronoun, there are two possibilities. Compare:
-  It is I who am responsible. (formal)
   It's me that's/who's responsible. (informal)
-  It is you who are in the wrong. (formal)
   It's you that's in the wrong. (informal)
To avoid being either too formal or too informal in this case, we could say, for example,
   I'm the person / the one who's responsible.

  • So there isn't any grammatical rule which explain(s?) the difference between I and me. It is a story of formal and informal form of the phrase? – jr28 Sep 25 '15 at 22:41
  • 1
    @jr28 I think we could say that. The formal vs. informal is actually the point of the grammar/usage of this structure. However, note the choices of the relative pronouns and the auxiliary verbs in the formal and informal alternatives. They are different. – Damkerng T. Sep 25 '15 at 22:44
  • 3
    By the way, I'm the one who . . . has actually become the most common choice in the last fifty years. – snailboat Sep 26 '15 at 1:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.