2
  1. I am happy seeing you succeed.

I am happy to see you succeed.

  1. I want you to succeed.

I want you succeeding.

I want your succeeding.

Could you please explain the differences between them, and the first and second examples independently of each other?

  • 1
    Where is a noun? The pattern is "adjective + to infinitive " , the second one is "verb + to infinitive ". – V.V. Nov 23 '15 at 3:05
1

I am happy seeing you succeed.

This means, effectively, I am happy while I'm seeing you succeed. There is a slight implication of causality -- I am happy because I see you succeeding -- but not that strong.

For example, if I said, "I am happy waiting here", I would mean that waiting is acceptable, that it would not make me unhappy to wait while the other person went and did something.

I am happy to see you succeed.

This could mean exactly what you think -- I am happy because I see you succeeding -- but in other constructions it could mean I am volunteering for something, or saying I would stand by while it happened. "I am happy to help you move" is me volunteering to help. "I am happy to watch you kill yourself" is a way of saying I won't interfere.

I want you to succeed.

This can only be interpreted literally.

I want you succeeding.

This means "I want to maintain you in the state of being successful". A doctor might say, "I want you exercising and eating right" -- he wants you to do that every day.

I want your succeeding.

This is grammatically correct but not idiomatic. "Your succeeding" is a legitimate noun-phrase, but saying "I want it" usually means I want to possess something, not that I want that thing to occur. So "I want a birthday party" sounds childish; says, "I want to have a birthday party."

"Your succeeding is important to me" is more idiomatic, but using the gerund "succeeding" as a noun sounds odd when there is an independent noun "success" that could be used instead.

0

English verb allows a limited set of possible forms in its complements:

I want you to + [verb]

  • I want you to succeed.
  • I want you to talk.

happy to + [something}

  • I am happy to see you succeed.
  • They are happy to see me doing well.

I want your + [noun]

  • I want your success.
  • I want your love.
0

In some cases, the construct is a gerund - a verb's present participle being used in a phrase as a noun. e.g. "Seeing you succeed, I decided to work harder and apply myself".

So both option 1a) and 1b) are perfectly acceptable usage.

2a) - "I want you to succeed" - is fine.

2b) - "I want you succeeding" - is fine.

2c) - "I want your succeeding" is not fine. It is a present participle, but it is not being made into a gerund (a noun-equivalent) because it is not being placed in a phrase. As there is nothing to possess, the possessive form - "your" - is inapplicable.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.