5

My question is about absolute phrases.

The weather being nice, we decided to have a picnic.

Can we add "with" in front of the absolute phrase?

With the weather being nice, we decided to have a picnic.

  • What was bad with my edit? I made the title more readable, in order to help the visitors know right away what is being asked. – CowperKettle Nov 23 '15 at 12:00
  • I did not see your edit .I approved anderson's edit.What was your suggestion for the title? – Cihangir Çam Nov 23 '15 at 12:07
  • Ah, it was Anderson's edit. I beg your pardon. (0: I would've titled the question "Absolute phrase and 'with': "(With) the weather being nice, we decided to have a picnic."" – CowperKettle Nov 23 '15 at 12:21
  • You can add "with", but I would ask: exactly what meaning are you trying to convey? If you mean "because", there is a idiom what with that essentially means "because", used like "What with the weather being so bad, we decided to stay in." – stangdon Nov 23 '15 at 16:55
1

Yes, you can add "with" to the beginning of the sentence.

"the weather being nice" is a gerund - a present participle form of a verb, being used as a noun.

In spoken American English, it will also appear as: "We decided to have a picnic, what with the weather being nice and all".

0

"With the weather being nice, we decided to have a picnic" is perfectly acceptable English usage and, at least to my ear, preferable to "The weather being nice, we decided to have a picnic," which sounds a bit flat and lifeless. Where I grew up in the suburbs of Los Angeles, California, we would say, "With the weather being nice, we decided to go on a picnic." Looking at it now, I see that "go on a picnic" might be idiomatic, perhaps mid-western (as my parents were raised and university-educated in Oklahoma before moving to Los Angeles).

Examples: "Let's go on a picnic!" "We went on a nice picnic last weekend." "Isn't it fun to go on a picnic? "After getting sick on our way home, I was sorry we had gone to that group picnic." "Going on a picnic is one of my favorite things to do." And so forth.

Driving out to the country and going on a picnic with my parents and sister created some of my best and happiest memories from childhood. Picnics are special, and your use of "with" is correct.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.