If I am in Figi next week, I will be using my scuba diving gear.
If I am in Figi next week, I am using my scuba diving gear. (maybe incorrect)
I think the second sentence is incorrect. Can you point out why?
1
-
2Hi Graduate, please add more information because as it stands your question is simply proofreading! Can you point out which sentences you think might be correct, or what you're trying to convey with each, or where you think there might be a mistake? (If there are other problems beyond those you suspect, we will be sure to point them out, but we require you have at least one specific concern first.) – WendiKidd Jun 20 '13 at 2:07
-
Do you mean Fiji, rather than Figi? – Steve Melnikoff Jun 20 '13 at 16:17
7
If I am in Figi next week, I will use my scuba diving gear.
This sentence meets the grammatical requirement of First Conditional.
-
I don't understand why this should get even one downvote, let alone two. Have my upvote to help redress the balance! – FumbleFingers Jun 20 '13 at 2:19
-
@Fumble, agree. +1 to get the answer balanced. – user114 Jun 20 '13 at 2:44
-
1@Carlo_R. Probably got the down-vote because he didn't say "why". Not a good enough reason though, because the answer is correct and the link explains the 1st conditional well. – Mari-Lou A Jun 20 '13 at 9:20
-
1I'm not one of the down-voters, but I can understand it easily enough. The answer as written doesn't fully address the question, whether original or edit. It's an answer, and it's a good one, but it's not a direct answer to the question as it's written. Certainly not deserving of a down-vote, of course. – Jonathan Garber Jun 20 '13 at 15:48
-
1It seems one of the downvotes has now been reversed anyway. Personally, I usually only downvote if an answer is actually wrong, not just because it's "inadequate". But I do agree that in situations like this answers should normally copy or paraphrase important points made in any links. – FumbleFingers Jun 21 '13 at 12:50
0
In the second answer you are referring to a possible future event, then stating a dependent action in the present instead of the future.
Personally I would use "If I'm in Fiji next week, I'll use my scuba diving gear."
As an alternative, you could also use "If I am in Fiji next week, I am going to use/be using my scuba diving gear.".
