3

To me, it sounds no different at all but I'm not sure of it. Do they have the same meaning?

  1. You have nothing to do with it. OR It has nothing to do with you.

  2. 4am has nothing to do with your English level. OR Your English level has nothing to do with 4am.

For second example, I told one of my friend who read the reading practice at 4am as she was awoken and said "Tired 4am voice". I always adore her accent and pronunciation.

I have no idea how to provide my research for this kinda question. Thanks.

  • 1
    In the second example, you need to replace "is" with "has" – Senjougahara Hitagi Dec 12 '15 at 10:17
2

This expression X has nothing to do with Y can mean two things (at least):

  1. If Y is the word "you," it can mean X does not concern you. When used in this way, the expression can be used in a somewhat unmannerly way, as if to say, "X is none of your business!"

Ted: I think maybe you're spending too much money this Christmas.
Ed: What I put in my shopping cart has nothing to do with you.

  1. It can also mean X is not the cause of Y. In the following dialogue, assume Ned is a salesman who had no sales last month:

Ned: Our team won Team of the Month. We should go celebrate!
Ed: Ned, you had nothing to do with this award.

(That could be regarded as a harsh remark, but the phrase can also be used in a reassuring way, to say that something is not your fault:)

Jed: What a calamity! I feel so bad that this happened.
Ed: Don't fret about it, Jed. You had nothing to do with this.

Back to what you were trying to say:

4am has nothing to do with your English.

I guess I can sort of see how this might mean the time of day doesn't affect your English, but I'd probably not word it that way. Instead, I'd say something more along the lines of:

Your English is great, even at 4am.

As for the other way around:

Your English has nothing to do with 4am.

That one seems a bit harder to catch the meaning. I might word that like this:

Your English isn't affected by the time of day.
Your English is good round the clock.

  • Hi, thanks for your answer!! But you didn't seem to answer my question whether X and Y are interchangeable with the same meaning? – puputeh24 Dec 12 '15 at 13:38
  • @puputeh24 - I wouldn't go so far as to say they are "interchangeable," although I think the two expressions would be similar and related. I think it also depends on what X and Y are. – J.R. Dec 12 '15 at 19:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.