1
  • she stands/ is standing in the shade of a tree.
    (is standing is correct.)
  • The temple stands/ is standing in the heart of the city.
    (stands is correct).

As per grammar rules there are some verbs which are non progressive and that includes stand as well. In the above two sentences how do we apply that rule. Why is standing is wrong in second sentence and correct in first? Looking at the sentence I know they are to be used in that manner only but I want to correct myself with the grammar rules. Thanks in advance.

1

2 Answers 2

4

It's the distinction when using the present simple and present continuous.

The first sentence uses is standing since it's a temporary action, then you use the present continuous. (You don't stand in the shade unless you usually do it.)

The present simple is used for regular actions, habits or true facts, as shown in the second example.

0

The first sentence is temporary there for stands is wrong.and not linking to speaker there for standing is correct

But second sentence is permanent there for stands is correct

1
  • Can you edit this to explain further? It is rather hard to see what your point is and as far as the first sentence it does not seem quite right.
    – mdewey
    Commented Oct 18, 2021 at 15:37

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .