2

I was browsing this WritingPrompt and stumbled upon this:

The bartender put a palm on his waist, "Say what?"

As seen from the above, before the dialogue, there are no speech/writing/thinking verbs (say, wrote, thought, etc.), whatever they're called, yet a comma is used. Is that correct? Should it not be a period instead?

|improve this question
  • 1
    "You go away like this," he pointed to the thumb, "and come back like this," he touched the little finger. Every one laughed. -- He smiled, "I must make on Miss Barkley the impression of a man of sufficient wealth. You are my great and good friend and financial protector." -- He wiped his hands on his jumper and grinned. "You have a good time?" The others all grinned too. -- She looked at me, "And you do love me?" -- some examples from A Farewell to Arms by Ernest Hemingway. – Damkerng T. Jan 17 '16 at 17:25
  • @DamkerngT. Hmm, I'm even more confused. When should a comma be used then versus a period? Whenever an action merges with dialogue? Would something such as: He smiled, "Hello there." be correct then? – john2546 Jan 17 '16 at 18:36
  • "Correct" is a very tricky notion. I'd say, out of context, it probably isn't correct. But in the middle of a book, where a conversation is full in swing? No one is going to call it wrong. – modulusshift Jan 17 '16 at 18:57
2

I mean, it's a pretty arbitrary rule that every utterance in a book must be attached to "So-and-so said". That's why there are quotation marks, so that you know it's a quotation, even if it isn't marked as such with words. It's important to make sure you keep it clear which people are talking (though a lot of authors don't), but it's also important to keep the flow of narration.

The commas help with both. They attribute the quotation to the subject of the sentence, and they aren't as hard of a break in the flow as a period is.

|improve this answer
  • So generally speaking, in the examples I've given, it should usually be a period instead of a comma, but in instances when it, undesirably, breaks the flow of text, a comma is acceptable? – john2546 Jan 17 '16 at 19:39
  • It is not correct in the sense that the current formal style, as it has been for roughly the past century, maybe a century and a half, does not do this. Before that, periods were less common. We're already reaching the point where the language of our Declaration of Independence is slipping out of the general range of comprehension. And you should see how many commas were used in that introduction. – modulusshift Jan 18 '16 at 0:19
  • My point being, if you used this sort of grammar in a paper for elementary school, sure, it'd get some red marks. But it's another thing entirely to run into it out in the real world, where no one is going to grade your book as long as it reads well. Yes, it's definitely acceptable, but still not "correct". – modulusshift Jan 18 '16 at 0:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.