0

Suppose that somebody asks me how to reach a place when I am at my cousin's. I don't live there, but I know the place enough to give indications. Suppose that I tell that person to follow the street he is on for half a mile, and then take another road in direction of a specific town.

I always used street to mean a public road in a city/town, but what should I use when I am not sure if the road is still in the town territory?

I imagine that if I say street and the person notices he is already outside the town, he would think he went too ahead, and missed the one I was talking of. If I say road when the road is still in the town territory, he could think he is supposed to go further ahead (and probably I was not precise when I said half of a mile).

Is there any way to avoid this kind of ambiguity, or isn't there any ambiguity at all?

  • kiam, I think "I always used" is not idiomatic English. As far as I know, with "always", and "never", you should say "I have always used". Please, if you verify this is a valid 'rule', give me a feedback, thank you! – user114 Jul 7 '13 at 10:42
  • 2
    @Carlo_R.: Not really – have a look. – J.R. Jul 7 '13 at 11:01
2

Although most passages are named streets in town, and roads in between towns, it doesn't confuse people to call them otherwise. If I say to someone, "Take that road that goes from downtown Boston to the harbor," they won't think, "What does he mean? It must be a street!" Or if I say, "the street between Boston and New York," it will sound a little funny, but they will still know what I mean.

And certainly, there are streets within towns that are named Something-or-Other Road.

So using the word "road" or "street" is not really enough to tell someone whether they are in a town or outside a town, and whichever word you use is not enough to make them wonder whether you mean they are in a town or not. If you are wondering whether you are talking about being in a town or not, just say so to the person you are talking to.

  • 1
    John, so, if "the street between Boston and NY" sounds funny, but "take the road that goes from ..." doesn't sound so, it is because "road" is a hypernym of "street", perhaps? – user114 Jul 7 '13 at 10:32
  • I would agree. Moreover, in the context of giving directions, I'd say that street and road are pretty much interchangeable, at least in much of the U.S. – J.R. Jul 7 '13 at 11:02
  • 2
    @Carlo_R. I would say you're right; "road" seems superordinate to "street," although I agree with J.R. that they are somewhat interchangeable. – John M. Landsberg Jul 7 '13 at 11:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.