English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
Yesterday, I received an email from Sun Jay, a sales manager of Panasonic, the leading manufacturer of robotics arm in the United Kingdom, on the status of the visit of our client to his factory.
Please comment on the article usage of above sentences -- a sales manager means that there are many sales managers in Panasonic, is it correct?
Does "a sales manager of Panasonic" mean that there are many sales managers at Panasonic?
The only real answer is: it's a little ambiguous. Probably "yes", but it's hard to know for sure.
This is because of the way indefinite and definite articles work in English. It's very common to use a when we're talking about someone's profession, because we're just saying that they're an example of that profession. For example,
Samir is a nurse.
Joon is a musician.
If we say
Dmitri is the cook at the restaurant
that means there is only one cook, Dmitri.
But when we use "a" with something more specific (like "of Panasonic"), it's unclear. For example, if I said
Berndt is a lawyer in Mecklenburg
he might be the only lawyer in Mecklenburg, or he might be one of many. There is no way to know. When we read
Sun Jay, a sales manager of Panasonic
the best guess is that yes, there is more than one sales manager at Panasonic, because if there was only one sales manager, it would be clearer and more common to say
Sun Jay, the sales manager of Panasonic.
