6

I have the following phrase:

Which of the activities in the photos look the most fun?

Can you explain why it's "look" and not "looks"?

22

Assuming that you found the question here, we can reasonably guess that the authors want readers to be free to choose more than one activity as being (among) the most fun.

In that case, which is a relative pronoun representing a plural subject (activities). We can see why look belongs in its plural form if we replace the pronoun which with [which + the name of the subject] and arrange the sentence into an imperative instead of its question form:

Tell your partner which activities, of the activities in the photos, look the most fun.

A possible response, using a plural subject with look as a present simple verb in plural form might be:

Gardening and eating look the most fun to me. I love growing and eating food.

Subjects and verbs generally need to agree in number to be accepted by some readers and listeners.

For example, I lives in a zoo is something that many would accept only from an animal.

In certain cases, it is relatively more common for native speakers to say things where subjects and verbs disagree in number, and oftentimes, especially in speech, listeners tend to accept them with no problem. This is especially true when a noun from the differing number case appears between the subject and the verb:

[Section under construction!]

If the intention is to ask the reader to choose only one activity as the single most fun, then the question is really which one, and in that case, look should agree with this subject and be made singular in form by adding s.

Which [one] of the activities in the photos looks the most fun?

But, as we've observed, which can be a pronoun representing a subset of two or more of the activities. In that case, the word most indicates that a selected subset would be compared to one or more other subsets.

  • 1
    @Ara Thanks for your earlier help in correcting my answer. – Jim Reynolds Jan 28 '16 at 16:15
  • 1
    I would say "which of these activities" if I was expecting more than one of the activities to be an answer. – ColleenV parted ways Jan 28 '16 at 19:16
  • 2
    Maybe it would help to define "felicitous"? I'm a native speaker and only learned that word this year, I doubt most learners know it. Otherwise, +1, although perhaps your final paragraph should stand out more, since it's the part that answers the question. – Azor Ahai Jan 28 '16 at 19:17
  • 1
    I agree there should be more emphasis on the final paragraph. In particular, I think the speaker could potentially indicate whether they want one or more than one activity given as an answer by their use of "look" or "looks." – Kyle Strand Jan 28 '16 at 23:36
  • @Col Your phrasing would only emphasize that the photos contain multiple activities, which is already signaled by the noun's -ies ending of that noun. The pertinent question is whether the writer wants the reader to select only one most fun, a group of most fun. – Jim Reynolds Jan 29 '16 at 12:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.