4

Normally, there is a selection in advance of a raising cam, with each feeder course being associated with a particular selection device.

This sentence has been chosen from "Knitting Technology" by David J Spencer. If I write the above sentence in the following way, i.e if I omit with before the absolute clause, what differences will be appeared?

Normally, there is a selection in advance of a raising cam, each feeder course being associated with a particular selection device.

I would appreciate it if anybody helped me to get rid from this awkward situation.

4

With-construction: I can't work with all the children crying. "with + a participle construction" expresses a special circumstance of the main clause. Sometimes "with" can be dropped. But sometimes the connection between main clause and participle construction can become unclear as in this case:

I can't work, all the children crying.

Added: An old post of mine on another forum: with-construction (with + noun + participle)

If you don't know this special construction, you have difficulty to understand it.

A typical example: I can't work | with all the children crying. The sense of it is: I can't work when all the children are crying. This construction is very old and was already in use in Latin (ablativus absolutus).

You can choose whether you consider "crying" as a participle or gerund. Grammars treat it as participle. I tend to see it as gerund and explain the sentence as - I can't work with all the children (in the act of) crying.

Of course, it will take you quite a time till you can think in such constructions. The advantage of the with-construction is you can add in a shortened and elegant way circumstantial facts for which you normally need a subclause with a conjunction.

This is a whole chapter in grammars and you should have a lot of examples as there are some variants of this with-construction (My name as there is no standard term for this construction).

2

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.