6

Is there a rule about when an adjective should end with "ic" or "ical"?

Geometr-ic
Analyt-ical
Theoret-ical
Kinet-ic

  • 1
    meta, "The Cambridge Guide to English Usage" has an entry named "-ic/-ical" in which it is said "Is there any reason for preferring one over the other? Often the answer is no." What does "Often" mean there? "Often" means that you should consult a dictionary each time you have to use an ic/ical adjective! – user114 Jul 16 '13 at 21:28
  • 1
    ... in fact in certain cases there is a great divergence in meaning, like it happen to econimic/al, historic/al and politic/al, but, fortunately, apart kinetic/al, the other adjectives you cited don't have this problem. – user114 Jul 16 '13 at 21:36
  • 1
    There's some very useful information in this answer to a similar question on ELU, but the bottom line, as @Carlo says, is that you probably ought to consult a dictionary fairly often (but if you don't have any reference tools to hand and you have to make a choice on the fly, you'll get it right more often than not if you always go for -ic). – FumbleFingers Jul 16 '13 at 21:37
4

The NOAD says that the -ical suffix is used to form adjectives:

  • Corresponding to nouns or adjectives usually ending in -ic (such as comical corresponding to comic)
  • Corresponding to nouns ending in -y (such as pathological corresponding to pathology)

As for the words you list, the NOAD says:

  • Geometric and geometrical are both adjectives, with the latter being a derivative of the first
  • Analytic is another term for analytical
  • Theoretic is another term for theoretical
  • Kinetical is not a word listed by the NOAD

In some cases, a suffix is preferred over the other one, but there isn't a rule that explains in every case when to use one or the other.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.