2

1.The sudden change in temperature can cause rocks to shatter.
2.The sudden change of temperature can cause rocks to shatter.

I'd like to know if the two sentences are the same in meaning or if there is any difference between them. Thanks in advance.

3
  • Change in is used to mean the process of something becoming different, where change of is used to when something is replaces by something else. So the correct use is "The sudden change in temperature. .
    – Khan
    Commented Feb 20, 2016 at 18:02
  • Thanks,Khan. I agree with you.Your comment is very helpful.
    – yethu
    Commented Feb 21, 2016 at 1:43
  • 2
    I think you could use either preposition. However, without more context, I think your sentence should probably begin with an indefinite article: A sudden change in/of temperature can cause rocks to shatter.
    – J.R.
    Commented Feb 21, 2016 at 18:36

2 Answers 2

3

Either sentence could work - There is very little effective difference between these two phrasings.

1.The sudden change in temperature can cause rocks to shatter.

...in temperature draws my attention to the ambient/external temperature around the rocks. Their surroundings have changed temperature, which we presume will cause the rocks to change temperature and shatter.

  1. The sudden change of temperature can cause rocks to shatter.

In a very subtle way, this suggests that the internal temperature of the rocks has changed.

Neither of these interpretations is totally rigid, though - I can see them being used interchangeably with no lost understanding.


More important. Unless these sentences directly follow a specific cause of the temperature change, you probably don't want the direct article, the. For example:

It is scorching hot here during the day, but every night, the fish company dumps a huge truck full of crushed ice on the landscaped gravel. The sudden change of temperature can cause the rocks to shatter.

We already know about the temperature change being referred to.

But when we don't know the cause of the temperature change:

These rocks are resistant to being crushed by heavy weights, but they are sensitive to other factors. A sudden change in temperature can cause the rocks to shatter.

We aren't talking about a specific temperature change - any will do. This could also be written:

These rocks are resistant to being crushed by heavy weights, but they are sensitive to other factors. Sudden temperature changes can cause the rocks to shatter.

AmE

0

Do you mean that the sudden change in temperature (on the moon) can cause rocks to shatter? You can use in or of.

1
  • I'd like to read another explanation with regard to my post. Thanks a million.
    – yethu
    Commented Feb 22, 2016 at 12:49

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .