0

Is there a difference between thses two sentences?

Do you need help (studying for the test)?

vs

Do you need any help (studying for the test)?

I wonder if they can be interchangeable when I want to help someone study for a test.

  • 2
    There's no practical difference between the two; you can use either and be understood perfectly well. – WendiKidd Jul 23 '13 at 21:40
2

There is absolutely no difference between the two. Both

Do you need help studying for the test?

and

Do you need any help studying for the test?

Are completely the same thing and are totally interchangeable.

|improve this answer|||||
  • OK! I thought that "help" without "any" might refer to something more specific or something. – jess Jul 23 '13 at 22:39
  • 2
    @jess: Usually adding any to a statement will make it more broad. In this case though, help is an already broad topic so it doesn't change the meaning in any tangible way. – Jacobm001 Jul 23 '13 at 22:52
2

I'd like to point out that different sentences like this can have convey nuances of communication outside the main idea, related to social relationship, interaction, emotional intelligence, etc.

(Bold text below marks parallel constructions; it is not intended as verbal emphasis.)

  • Do you need help studying for the test?

    This is a little abrupt. Imagine a person behind a desk that reads (silently) from a checklist, "Needs help studying for test: Yes/No" and then asks the question above. This form of question would occur more often from someone direct, sharp, not interested in actually giving help, or someone very logically minded.

  • Do you need some help studying for the test?

    As a rule of thumb, more words are "softer", "nicer", or "more polite". "Some" may indicate a non-trivial amount of time, such as a willingness (or desire) from the asking person to spend time with the person. This perspective might be emphasized as, "Would you like some help studying for the test?"

  • Do you need any help studying for the test? "Any" is the broadest and most open-ended sense of help which frees the other person to ask anything. "No, but do you know a good website for this?" Or they might consider it an open ended offer without a time limit.

Note: The above scenarios are only possible meanings which are highly dependent on context. I'm not suggesting any of the above should be considered valid for all contexts. I'm just pointing out the general idea that filler words can soften the question and perhaps make you seem more friendly or polite (yet less direct).

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.