4

I'm currently pronouncing:

  • g as /dgi/
  • j as /djay/

I'm not sure if this is the American or Britisch way to pronounce it.

If it depends on the choice of words, I was just singing the alphabet.
Question: I was wondering what is the correct way of pronouncing these letters in American English and British English?

EDIT: I don't need to know the difference in a context of a sentence or a word. Just the difference while singing the alphabet in American English and British English.

  • I sing g as /jee/ and j as /jey/ or /jei/. – shin Apr 12 '16 at 9:52
  • 2
    Do you just mean when reciting the alphabet, or in the context of words? Because the specific word can make a big difference in the pronunciation of g and j. – stangdon Apr 12 '16 at 12:29
  • @stangdon just as I mentioned, like while singing the alphabet. – Decypher Apr 12 '16 at 13:11
  • Oxford learner's dictionary can help with both AmE and BrE pronunciations of letters, for example, oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/pronunciation/english/g_1 – ColleenV Apr 12 '16 at 16:24
  • I occasionally hear gibber pronounced with a "hard" g (i,e. - /ˈɡɪbə/ rather than /ˈdʒɪbə/), but I don't know if this (or any similar) represents regional variation such as AmE/BrE. OP's /dgi/ and /djay/ simply don't correspond to anything familiar to me (they're not valid IPA anyway). – FumbleFingers Apr 12 '16 at 17:11
6

The letter G is called /dʒi:/ in both British and American English. It rhymes with see.

The letter J is called /dʒeɪ/ in in both British and American English. It rhymes with say.

4

In The Cambridge Encyclopedia of The English Language, David Crystal notes 'no important regional variation' in the pronunciation of 'j' (dz) as a consonant. But there are regional variations in the 'ee' and especially in the 'ay'. (I am Australian and might say (but not sing) closer to 'jay-ee'.)

4

There is no difference in the names or pronounciations of the letters G and J in any English dialect. They are called "Jee" and "Jay" respectively (with the consonant pronounced like a combination of "d" and the French "j").

There are notable differences in other letters: Z is called "Zed" in most of the English-speaking countries, but "Zee" in the US; and the name of the letter H is usually pronounced "Eitch", but in some UK regions it is distinctly pronounced "Heitch".

  • I don't think French has the /dʒ/ that we use at the beginning of /dʒi:/ or /dʒeɪ/ does it? It only has the /ʒ/ sound that we hear in words like jamais, doesn't it? – Araucaria Apr 12 '16 at 19:51
  • 1
    @Araucaria: when French /d/ (represented by "d") is followed by French /ʒ/ (represented by "j"), we get the same sound as English /dʒ/, more or less. In French, "dj" mainly occurs in loanwords such as "djinn." – sumelic Apr 13 '16 at 0:38
  • @sumelic So the word djinn is pronounced with a /dʒ/ not a /ʒ/? – Araucaria Apr 13 '16 at 0:41
  • @Araucaria: Yes. I only know of "dj" occurring in loanwords from Arabic, but I think the sound is used in some loanwords from English as well. – sumelic Apr 13 '16 at 0:42
  • I must have been having a brainstorm when I commentd before. Your categorical answer here is categorically wrong! In Scottish English J is most often pronounced /dʒaɪ/, rhymes with pie. As noted by Michael below. – Araucaria Aug 9 at 17:13
3

Many Scottish people pronounce j 'jye' (to rhyme with eye, fly, sigh etc). Can make a telephone conversation tricky if they are spelling something.

1

there is a rule:

It states any "g" followed by i,e,or y might say 'j'

eg: gym. gel, giant.

Although the stated rule holds good in most cases, there are a lot of exceptions and unfortunately some of those exceptions happen to be common words; "get" and "give" are two examples. "Margarine", "gaol" and "gynaecologist" also break the rule.

Sometimes, if we don't want "g" to say "j", we add a "u". We don't usually pronounce it, it's just there to keep the "g" hard: "disguise", "guest" and "vague" are examples of this.

  • 1
    That rule would be better stated as: 'g' followed by i, e, or y might say 'j', because it's really pointing out that we use the "hard g" when the 'g' is followed by 'a' or 'o'. – J.R. Apr 12 '16 at 12:33
  • But is there a difference in pronouncing it in US or Britisch english when singing the alphabet? I didn't ask about how to pronounce it in a context ( of a word), only purely in the alphabet and if there is a difference between US or Britisch pronuciation. – Decypher Apr 12 '16 at 13:15
  • I am not a native speaker.But I can say that I didn't realize any serious differences unless you want to make petty distinctions.So I recommend not wasting time splitting hairs. – Mia Apr 12 '16 at 13:20
1

But is there a difference in pronouncing it in US or Britisch english when singing the alphabet? I didn't ask about how to pronounce it in a context ( of a word), only purely in the alphabet and if there is a difference between US or Britisch pronuciation.

There is no difference. When you say 'singing' the alphabet, do you mean you sing it like a song? To a tune? If you just say the letters, as most people do, then you are reciting the alphabet.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.