1

I've learnt that past perfect tense should be used when an action had happened before another action in the past. For example, I had took the introduced class before I registered the advanced class. And, I've also learnt that the past participle verb can be used as an adjective to describe the noun. For example, challenge accepted.

The situation was talking about a photo of me that was taken by others. Now, I'm wondering the sentence "I had it taken recently." If it is a past tense (had) and the past participle adjective (taken) in a sentence or the past perfect tense (had taken) in the sentence.

Free feel to edit my post, and sorry for my poor English.

  • To “have something done” is a pattern that means that someone else is doing a service for us. – userr2684291 May 11 '16 at 1:40
2

I had it taken recently is definitely NOT in the past perfect!

I took it recently = You did it yourself.
I had it taken recently = You asked someone to do it for you.

(Both sentences are in the simple past.)


BACKGROUND

The name "past participle" is a rather unfortunate one. It's one of the sources of confusion in English grammar learning. This is mainly because the English passive voice and the English perfect use the same form of verb, i.e., the past participle form of a verb.

I quoted an entry in a grammar book once, in this answer (follow the link for more information). To demonstrate this point with the same examples, I'll discuss them, briefly, below:

Past participles are used to make both passive verb forms and active perfect tenses. Compare: (1) He was calling. (active - past progressive)
(2) He was called. (passive - simple past)
(3) He has called. (active - present perfect)

In (2), called, the past participle form of call, is used after the auxiliary verb BE in its past form, was. A main verb in its past participle form after BE indicates that the clause is in the passive voice. In this example, someone called him -- he was called -- he was called by someone.

In (3), called, again the past participle form of call, is used after the auxiliary verb HAVE in its singular-present form, has. A main verb in its past participle form after HAVE indicates that the clause is in a perfect tense, in this case the present prefect. In this example, let's say that someone ask you, "Jack told me he'd call the lieutenant today. Has he called?" and because Jack has done so, you may reply, "He has called."


BACK TO OUR QUESTION (BARE PASSIVES, e.g., have something done)

The confusion caused by your sentence, I had it taken recently, is perfectly understandable, because in this sentence, had is the main verb, NOT an auxiliary verb. This is a special use of have, as defined in the Macmillan Dictionary in definition 14, like this:

have
[transitive] [never passive] to arrange for something to be done or for someone to do something
have something done: The place is looking much better since they had it redecorated.
She wanted to have her portrait painted by a famous artist.
have someone do something: I’ll have someone bring your luggage up right away.

So, I had it taken already means that you asked someone to take the photo, and the photo had already taken.

One way to explain the syntax of have something done is to treat it as a bare passive that complements the main verb (typical verbs of that allows bare passive complements are have, get, order, and other sense verbs such as see).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.