Are both these statements correct?

  • How many onions do you want?

  • How much onion do you want?

I feel as if the latter is wrong but I know not why.


They are both correct, given proper context.

If you want to ask someone how many whole onions, they want, you use the former:

A: I need you to get onions from the store.
B: How many onions do you want?
A: Three or four, please.

Note that the answer can be fractional:

A: I need onions for this recipe, can you get some from the store?
B: How many onions does the recipe call for?
A: One and a half large onions, so if you could buy two, that would be great.

This is the more common usage.

However, if you want a volume of onion, either chopped or prepared in some way, you would use "much".

A: This recipe calls for a lot of chopped onion!
B: How much onion does it need?
A: Three cups!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.