2

I've learned that second condition is used to talk about unreal or unlikely or hypothetical condition. But some kind of 2nd conditional sentence construction are confusing to me. They are:

  1. If I were going to climb up mountain, I would be taking a walking stick with me.

(This sentence is created by myself by looking at Englishpage.com (mixed conditionals), the sentence that I looked at in this site was: If I were going to Fiji next week, I would be taking my scuba diving gear with me. I could write this sentence in question itself but don't understand its words)

(Can i say: if I were going to climb up mountain, I would take a walking stick ? Does it make sense? Why continuous form (would be+v4) has been used in the above above instead of would+v1 ?)

Again, in the same way, the following sentence is also followed by continuous form(would be+v4) in the main clause, why? The sentence is:

  1. I am busy next week, If I had time, I would be coming to your party.
    (Englishpage.com, same page)

(Can we say: I'm busy next week, if I had time , I would come to your party ?)

Again, what is the difference between following sentences:

1.If I were going to Rome next week, I would be trying to find accomodation.

  1. If I were going to go to Rome, I would be trying to find accomodation.
Improve this question
2
  • Please cite your source (in which you found those sentences) and please check your spellings. Note that we don't write a space before a comma, and in standard written English, we use I when it should be used and we capitalize all Is when we mean "I".
    – Damkerng T.
    May 19, 2016 at 6:10
  • I've edited my question. I've also presented its source. But i'm unable to give its links as i'm using simple mobile. Could you please google search my key words,you'll find that source.
    – yubraj
    May 19, 2016 at 7:03

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
1

Yes, you can say this:

If I were going to climb a mountain, I would take a walking stick.

I'm busy next week; if I had time, I would come to your party.

This is more commonly used than the following:

If I were going to climb a mountain, I would be taking a walking stick.

I'm busy next week; if I had time, I would be coming to your party.

Both ways of speaking are perfectly valid. There are a couple of subtle differences. I would be taking a walking stick implies that the action of taking the stick is important and on the person's mind during the walk. For example, maybe the stick is heavy and takes some concentration to handle correctly. Or maybe the walk is very long and difficult, and so it is quite important to bring the stick.

Also, I would be taking a walking stick is a second conditional statement, and it subtly implies that the mountain climb might not happen at all. People who speak like this are usually making clear that the situation is hypothetical and not necessarily going to happen.

I would be taking a walking stick implies that the action is somehow continuous during the walk. Something about taking the walking stick makes it active over a period of time (during the climb). I think a better example might be something like this: If I were going to climb a mountain, I would put a sandwich in my backpack. Compare this to the following: If I were going to climb a mountain, I would be carrying a gigantic sack full of food.

Improve this answer
3
  • Oh i see what you mean. Do you mean ' I would be taking a walking stick' implys that the speaker will be going to bring the walking stick in that hypothetical situation if he had time next week ? If so, would be+v4= going to something in the imaginary situation. Or intention of doing sth in the imaginary situation if sth condition meet to it?
    – yubraj
    May 19, 2016 at 9:41
  • I'm expecting your response in comment. I also request you to edite your answer as i edited my question
    – yubraj
    May 19, 2016 at 11:20
  • I would be taking a walking stick implies that the action is somehow continuous during the walk. Something about taking the walking stick makes it active over a period of time (during the climb). I think a better example might be something like this: If I were going to climb a mountain, I would put a sandwich in my backpack. Compare this to the following: If I were going to climb a mountain, I would be carrying the gigantic sack full of food.
    – Ringo
    May 19, 2016 at 19:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .