2

How do you differentiate between

He is playing in the field.

He is playing on, in the field.

Edit:I had seen most actually 'Virat playing on ,in the field' below an image.

  • 3
    The second phrase doesn't make any grammatical sense. Did you mean "Playing on the field?" Unless you mean something like "He is playing on, in the field". – Zessa May 31 '16 at 14:24
2

I agree with the others, "He is playing on, in the field." means someone continued playing in the field, with an implication that there was a reason they might have stopped. The sentence is perfectly valid, although it sounds a little awkward and rare.

Example 1: The child was allergic to pollen, but he played on, in the field. This is valid, except "playing on" almost always refers to sports.

Example 2: The footballer was hurt, but he played on, in the field. This is valid, but it sounds very strange to specify "in the field". The only place a sportsman could continue to play is on the sports field. I think the unusual/awkward phrase is explained by the fact that this was an image caption. The author was probably consciously constructing a caption for people who couldn't see the image. The image is a sportsman who stayed in the game, the awkward and redundant "in the field" was consciously added to create the mental imagery for people who couldn't see the picture.

  • I think you're right when you suggest that the awkwardness is because it is a photo caption. "In the field" might have been added for computer categorization of the images for searching or automatic placement, i.e. "John Smith, looking angry, in the field." – ColleenV May 31 '16 at 17:12
  • "in the field" could refer to the player's playing position in some sports (i.e., in a fielding position). – megaflop May 31 '16 at 18:10
8

"In the field" is where it is.

To "play on" means to continue to play, especially despite circumstances in which it might be better for play to end.

A dense fog has rolled in, but Manchester City want to play on.

He has strained a muscle, but is playing on.

He has strained a muscle, but is playing on in the field, not as catcher. [baseball example]

3

The second one - "he is playing on, in the field" - doesn't read very well. Did you see this sentence somewhere?

The only way I can imagine that sentence being used is if on is being used in the sense of "continue". We can say things like

He played on

to mean "He continued playing", or

Carry on

to mean "Please continue." So "He played on, in the field", could only mean "He continued playing, in the field." It does not scan very well, due to the two prepositions in a row, but it is grammatically correct.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.