4

It might seem a trivial question but it occured to me whlie I was writing for an assignment.

I know if I put a pair of in subject place, I should use a singular verb e.g. A pair of shoes is there. Does it work the other way around too?

What subject suits this sentence, a singular or plural one:

.... is/are a pair of shoes.

This is confusing for me because on the one hand when you point at some shoes actually you're showing something that is originally a plural noun so it must be addressed as plural. On the other hand we want to use a pair of which is singular. So which is correct?

It's a pair of shoes.

They're a pair of shoes.

  • Wow! I'm getting different answers. Well I'm not really in place to say which is right. – Yuri Jul 13 '16 at 21:02
2

In your examples, both are correct, but it depends on what you are referring to

It is a pair of shoes.
It is a pair of two halves.

It is a pair

in these examples one is describing the "pair"edness of the objects.

They are a pair of shoes.
Those are a nice pair of melons.

two somethings are a pair

in these examples one is describing the objects as a "pair".

  • Thank you Peter. Is this applicable to plural nouns that always are plural like jeans? I mean here again can we use both it's/they're a pair of jeans? – Yuri Jul 14 '16 at 9:46
1

Many group nouns can take either take a singular or plural conjugation depending on the dialect of the speaker. These include things like band, group, and pair. In general, BE prefers a plural form for these nouns and AmE a singular form.

EDIT: Here's some data from the GloWbE corpus for usage frequencies.

"Pair are":

Pair are

"Pair is":

Pair is

  • So both sentences are right? It's/They're a pair of shoes. – Yuri Jul 13 '16 at 18:27
  • Yes, essentially. I'd suggest you pick the one that corresponds to the variety of English you're learning, like AmE or BE, and stick to using it. – eijen Jul 13 '16 at 21:49
  • What about AusE and NZE? – 3kstc Jul 14 '16 at 6:14
  • @3kstc AusE and NZE "pair is" FREQ / SIZE (M) / PER MIL - AUS 81 / 148.2 / 0.55 | NZ 56 / 81.4 / 0.69. "Pair are" : AUS 53 / 148.2 / 0.36 | NZ 48 / 81.4 / 0.59. Queries: "pair is", "pair are" - select Frequency to see results. – eijen Jul 15 '16 at 0:00
0

It is a pair of shoes.

They are shoes.

Grammatically a pair is singular.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.