Questions tagged [backshifting]

The tag has no usage guidance, but it has a tag wiki.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
1
vote
1answer
24 views

“Everybody thought we should sell” vs “Everybody thought we should have sold”

Everybody thought we should sell Everybody thought we should have sold While I was watching the news, I came to wonder about this question. As far as I know, the tense after "that" should be ...
0
votes
1answer
26 views

Have you explained why you did/have done/had done?

Let’s say I know my friend has broken up with his girlfriend. I don’t know when, but I know he has. I want to know whether or not he’s given her brother an explanation. What should I ask? Have you ...
1
vote
2answers
47 views

future in reported speech when reporting verb is in the past

I have read the following sentence: He said he will follow me to the end. AFAIK in reported speech, the future tense is replaced with the conditional tense when the reporting verb is in the past. ...
0
votes
1answer
37 views

Should I backshift with “If you ever wondered…”?

Do I use present or past tense after the phrase "If you ever wondered"? Examples: If you ever wondered what hell looks like, ... If you ever wondered what hell looked like, ...
2
votes
1answer
12 views

Past simple in specific reported speech

I'm writing a short story for a C2 Creative Writing course, and I couldn't help but come across this question regarding reported speech. My main question is this: consider someone says, "I ate the ...
1
vote
1answer
31 views

Sequence of tences

Should you say me which is correct? Our teacher said the place where we were going to stay IS supposed to have beautiful paysages. Our teacher said the place where we were going to stay WAS ...
1
vote
1answer
25 views

backshifting past simple in that clauses

Let' say someone tells you the following about another person called George: George was a good guy. If this person means that George was a good guy but he no longer is, do I have to backshift the ...
0
votes
1answer
74 views

She said that she has/had seen a tiger

Which one is more correct: 1) She said that she has seen a tiger. 2) She said that she had seen a tiger.
0
votes
2answers
42 views

Why 'can', not 'could' in “She told us that we can use the kitchen.”?

Why 'can', not 'could' in "She told us that we can use the kitchen."? I thought that since the main verb is 'told' that the following sentence after 'that~' should use the past tense, 'could', too. ...
0
votes
1answer
45 views

Tenses in 'Did I tell you what happened to me?'

Why can't we use Past Perfect in the second clause of the sentence 'Did I tell you what happened to me?' if the second clause happened before 'Did I tell you' As far as I know, we use Past ...
1
vote
1answer
15 views

sequence of tenses issue (called)

I am wondering Which one is correct "I had a traditional Filipino dish that is called tinolang manok." or "I had a traditional Filipino dish that was called tinolang manok." Are both sentences ...
3
votes
1answer
786 views

She told me that she HAS / HAD a gun [duplicate]

I edited this question, since the original (or current one, revised by ColleenV) post has this sentence. For instance, in “She told me that she has a gun”, I edited this sentence to For ...
1
vote
1answer
52 views

Which one is the correct form of reported speech for the following sentence?

Which one is the correct form of reported speech for the following sentence? why? "When were you born?", he asked him. => 1- He asked him when he had been born. 2- He asked him when he was born....
3
votes
1answer
134 views

“she was raped” or “she had been raped” in this reported speech

A) A 21 year old girl studying in Vidynagar alleged that she was raped by a boy in a hotel in the city on August 23. Based on above complaint police arrested accuse. B) A 21 year old girl ...
1
vote
2answers
40 views

Are both of these sentences correct?

I have to transform the following sentence into indirect speech: 'I haven't got any money',he said My transformation is : He said he hadn't got any money. The answer key only lists He said ...
2
votes
1answer
56 views

Backshifting in Reported Speech

The exec was making a presentation to the company board."Computers have allowed us to cut costs," he explained. "We expect even more dramatic improvements as computers become increasingly self-...
2
votes
2answers
145 views

“If I knew what you want/wanted to eat tonight”

Context: I am talking to my friends, trying to find out what she wants to eat tonight. "What do you want to eat tonight?" "You know what I want to eat." "If I knew what you wanted to eat, I ...
1
vote
1answer
4k views

“I askED him if he knowS…” or “knew” - which one is correct?

I don't know why but when I say "I asked him if he knew..." type of sentences making both verbs past tense, it seems like I am saying it wrong... I already used the past tense verb in the first part ...
1
vote
2answers
8k views

How old were you?

Let's say I knew how old somebody is at the moment, but I forgot it. In that case, I think I can ask, "How old were you?", am I right?
5
votes
3answers
911 views

Changing the verb for indirect quote/reported speech expressing habitual actions

The below-mentioned question is asked in my exam, I think my answer is correct, please tell if I am right, I have to challenge the question in 2 days if its answer given is wrong. correct answer is ...
3
votes
2answers
73 views

Should I treat quotes from God as universal truth for narration?

This is totally for my assignment not a theist atheist thing. Actually the sentence I need to narrate is Lord Shiva once said, "I am responsible for everything." Now Shiva is actually a Hindu god ...
2
votes
1answer
190 views

“until something” in reported speech

How can I transform the following sentence into reported speech? Let's say my colleague said to me: I will practice until I reach my goal If I want to say it in reported speech, should it be ...
2
votes
1answer
2k views

Facts in reported speech – to backshift or not

Are these two sentences right ? Mona told me that London was the biggest city in England. He wanted to know where Manchester was. I found these two sentences by chance in exercise book ...
1
vote
1answer
32 views

Reported speech uncertainty

Can you help me with these? Which of them are correct or sound more natural? How far into the sentence does the reported speech go- I feel like if I transform everything it changes the meaning and ...
2
votes
1answer
10k views

'would have had to

I found this passage from my reading book so it couldn't be wrong :D But I don't get it! It used to be that if you wanted to watch a movie, you'd have to watch it from your television. I think my ...
0
votes
1answer
2k views

Is the sentence 'Tom said he hadn't got any money' reported speech from 'Tom said, “I haven't got any money”'?

I came across this pair of sentences in 'Cambridge English Preliminary for Schools Trainer' by Sue Elliott and Liz Gallivan CUP 2012: Tom said he hadn't got any money. Tom said, 'I haven't got any ...
1
vote
1answer
19 views

incorrect time in the sentence?

This sentence is from some game manual: For example, if a player started a battle with a “XYZ” Order and then attempts diplomacy with the card bonus, he must retreat if he draws a "HJK" Is that ...
2
votes
1answer
125 views

Sequence of tenses for facts irrelevant of the moment of speech

Let's consider two sentences: (1) I suggested that the word zeitgeist was of German origin. (2) The lecturer said the Pluto's orbital period is more than 200 years. In both cases, the facts are ...
1
vote
2answers
183 views

He said that his job IS/WAS boring

before few weeks my friend said: "my job is boring" I need to report his speech to third person, What should I say? and why? He said that his job is boring. He said that his job was boring.
1
vote
3answers
2k views

“I thought you WRITE or WROTE poetry” - which is correct?

Could you tell me if I want to inquire a person what he does and he answers that he writes fiction and I tell him "I thought you wrote poetry." Or "I thought you WRITE poetry.", the action is in the ...
1
vote
2answers
361 views

Tense agreement: “confirmed it is” v.s. “confirmed it was”

Google:"confirmed it is" Google:"confirmed it was" Both have >400k hits but from what I learned in school, the former is ungrammatical. Or is it not? IBM confirmed it is building more data centres ...
1
vote
1answer
56 views

Is a verb missing from “…the company had turned away from DJs and towards the audiophile market…”?

From the article Technics’ new “standard” SL-1200GR turntable expected to cost $2,000 on factmag.com: Earlier this week, Technics’ creative director Hiro Morishita told The New York Times why the ...
1
vote
2answers
242 views

confusion over which tense: Present Simple or?

A few weeks ago, I sent a message to a foreign friend when I heard a earthquake happened in her country. But the message didn't send successfully. Today she contacted me, I gave her a message like ...
2
votes
2answers
395 views

Confusion about “Backshift” of Verbs in Indirect Speech (To Kill a Mockingbird)

The following are some lines from To Kill a Mockingbird: I maintain that the Ewells started it all, but Jem, who was four years my senior, said it (had started?) started long before that. He said ...
2
votes
2answers
80 views

a question about tense backshifting

The mom had prepared some food for her son before he left. The mom had prepared some food for her son before he was going to leave. The mon had prepared some food for her son before leaving. Do ...
1
vote
1answer
42 views

the backshifting in one sentence

Wisconsin has dissected Zellner's court filing to determine evidence that was overlooked at the time Avery was convicted of killing Halbach. Zellner contends that the new battery of tests can be done ...
1
vote
1answer
103 views

mixing tenses in a sentence with “while” [duplicate]

The following is an excerpt from the Washington Post article, titled "When did the world turn against Justin Timberlake and embrace Britney Spears?": They had a bad break-up three years later. ...
0
votes
1answer
646 views

“He didn't say he liked coffee” or “He didn't say he likes coffee”?

According to this link, the verb tense in the subordinate clause can be either present or past tense when the main clause's verb is in past tense IF the fact stated in the subordinate clause still ...
10
votes
5answers
5k views

Why is this sentence wrong “He wasn't a stranger because I have met him before”?

"He wasn't a stranger because I have met him before." What's wrong with this sentences?
1
vote
2answers
69 views

Is past tense “existed” obligatory in “You could show that the amino acid now existed as a negative ion using electrophoresis.”

From Chemguide: Adding an alkali to an amino acid solution: If you increase the pH of a solution of an amino acid by adding hydroxide ions, the hydrogen ion is removed from the -NH3+ group. ...
1
vote
1answer
4k views

When she said that she loves or loved

Which one of these two sentences is correct? When she said that she loved me When she said that she loves me
1
vote
1answer
66 views

backshifting of the “had to”

There are many sites explaining the rules of backshifting in the reported speech but I am not able to find the one for backshifting of "had to". I had to do it, he said. Which is the correct form ...
2
votes
1answer
63 views

backshifting in the context of one clause

The other [feature] was Schmitt's characterization of all legal norms as resting, explicitly or implicitly, on a sovereign decision, which either applied rules generally to people's actions or ...
0
votes
2answers
66 views

Choice of tense and meaning in “My friend considered going to an event where X came (had come?)” [duplicate]

My friend considered going to an event to see X. Now if I wanted to convey a similar meaning, which of the sentences below would you suggest I use? And what's the difference between the two? My ...
2
votes
1answer
413 views

“Bare infinitive” vs. “perfect infinitive” in past time narration

They emerged from the tunnel and were on the airport highway, with its lights on both sides attached to tall standards. Witty had watched Hardy operating the automobile at first, and had not ...
2
votes
2answers
4k views

Difference in “was having dinner” & “had been having dinner”

1.He said that he was having dinner when they knocked on the door. 2.He said that he had been having dinner when they knocked on the door. What is the difference in using past continuous & ...
9
votes
3answers
1k views

The teacher told us that ice {floats/floated} on water [duplicate]

If: The teacher said to the students, "Ice floats on water." Then did: The teacher told the students that ice floats on water. The teacher told the students that ice floated on water. ...
7
votes
3answers
166 views

Meanng of past-tense “wished” in “If I bought that apartment, we'd have a place to party whenever we wished”

Both these conditional sentences are grammatical: If I bought that apartment, we'd have a place to party whenever we wish. If I bought that apartment, we'd have a place to party whenever we ...
1
vote
2answers
1k views

Which tense is better: “He wanted me to ask you how you were (are?) doing.”

I bumped into him on my way back home. He wanted me to ask you how you were doing. I bumped into him on my way back home. He wanted me to ask you how you are doing. Are both the above sentences ...
2
votes
1answer
58 views

tenses/ backshifting died/dies

I would love you till the sun died. I would love you till the sun dies. Are both of them grammatically correct? Is there a difference in their meaning?