Skip to main content
2 of 4
added 38 characters in body
user avatar
user avatar

Motional be

In The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language (p.113-4), this is called "motional be", and it's very unusual as English verbs go. In this meaning, be appears only in perfect constructions:

(present perfect)  We have been to Paris twice.
(past perfect)    By 2008, we had been to Paris twice already.

This is not possible without the perfect:

(present simple)  *We are to Paris.   ← ungrammatical
(past simple)    *We were to Paris.   ← ungrammatical

The perfect construction have been to X is an experiential perfect. It means you've gone to X in the past and have (probably) since left; now you have the experience of having gone there.

user230