In the sentence: > They also live in Argentina, Bolivia and Ecuador where they reside mainly on estuaries, lagoons, mud flats and salt lakes. we can distinguish two clauses. The **main clause**: > They also live in Argentina, Bolivia and Ecuador. and a **subordinate clause**: > where they reside mainly on estuaries, lagoons, mud flats and salt lakes. Note that the meaning of the main clause doesn't change if the subordinate clause is removed. --- The following is my understanding of the usage of comma and *"where"* that I have come across: - **A comma is advised** if the *where*-clause **can be removed** without altering the meaning of the main clause. For example: > I first saw him in Paris, where I lived in the early sixties - **A comma is advised** if the *where*-clause **cannot be removed**. For example: > This is where I live --- Hence, in the OP's quote I would use a comma: > They also live in Argentina, Bolivia and Ecuador, where they reside mainly on estuaries, lagoons, mud flats and salt lakes.