Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by ColleenV
Bounty Ended with fev's answer chosen by ColleenV
Notice added Draw attention by ColleenV
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by ColleenV
added 266 characters in body
Source Link
MJ Ada
  • 231
  • 1
  • 11

How does 'both' function in the example below? Is the determiner modifying the entire noun phrase 'Jack and Jane'? I know this is correct English; however, in most examples, determiners only modify a single noun.

Both Jack and Jane got on the bus.

I think it's worth highlighting the difference between 'both' and 'the'. You could rewrite 'the fathers and mothers' as 'the fathers and the mothers', but you can't write 'both Jack and both Jane'. In my example, the 'both' only makes sense when it is used once.

How does 'both' function in the example below? Is the determiner modifying the entire noun phrase 'Jack and Jane'? I know this is correct English; however, in most examples, determiners only modify a single noun.

Both Jack and Jane got on the bus.

How does 'both' function in the example below? Is the determiner modifying the entire noun phrase 'Jack and Jane'? I know this is correct English; however, in most examples, determiners only modify a single noun.

Both Jack and Jane got on the bus.

I think it's worth highlighting the difference between 'both' and 'the'. You could rewrite 'the fathers and mothers' as 'the fathers and the mothers', but you can't write 'both Jack and both Jane'. In my example, the 'both' only makes sense when it is used once.

Source Link
MJ Ada
  • 231
  • 1
  • 11

Can determiners modify noun phrases?

How does 'both' function in the example below? Is the determiner modifying the entire noun phrase 'Jack and Jane'? I know this is correct English; however, in most examples, determiners only modify a single noun.

Both Jack and Jane got on the bus.