2

I have a list of words and their meanings. The word "subtle" is defined here as "discriminating." I have been looking for their common definition for a long time, but didn't find anything worthy. In the site http://dictionary.reverso.net/english-definition/refined, it is stated that the 2nd definition of "refined" is "subtle; discriminating," but, anyway, I still can't understand what they do have in common.

Actually, two more dictionaries (not only reverso) use the definition "subtle; discriminating" together like synonyms: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/refined and even well-known Collins English Dictionary! https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/refined That's why, there must probably be something common between them.

  • 1
    There is no single synonym for subtle, and if there were, it would not be "discriminating". Try the OneLook aggregator. This will provide links to a dozen or more dictionaries. I wouldn't rely on "reverso". Look for the definition of subtle itself, and read all the definitions and all the examples. – P. E. Dant Jul 19 '17 at 7:54
  • 1
    That the combination "subtle; discriminating" is used in the definition of refined does not mean that subtle and discriminating are synonymous or related in any way; they're not. A subtle wit and discriminating taste are among the separate traits that a refined person displays. Forget about the definitions of "refined" and read up on "subtle". – P. E. Dant Jul 19 '17 at 19:13
2

Dictionary definitions can only hint at what these words mean. I'll illustrate them with a few well-known examples, a brief look at their etymologies, and lots of links to real, typical uses of the words. Real usage in context will give you a better understanding of these words than any abstract description.

Subtle

Subtle comes from Latin roots meaning "under the web" or "under the weave" (sub-tilis, related to "textile"), suggesting light, delicate fabric made of fine threads woven precisely. In English, this has given birth to a variety of extended meanings, some related to fine consistency, some to the keenness of mind needed to produce or perceive it, and some to both.

A "subtle distinction" is one that is very slight, so that you must pay very close attention to understand what makes the distinguished things different, such as the distinction in law between larceny and fraud. A "subtle odor" is one that can barely be perceived, because its concentration in the air is so low. A "subtle operation" is an action that requires precision and delicacy rather than force to be successful, such as assembling a watch or persuading a temperamental person to make a decision. Or a "subtle operation" can be one that works in ways that are hard to perceive or understand even if you're watching the action closely (it happens "under the weave"), such as the ways that power and status are established in social groups.

A "subtle mind" is one that perceives subtle things or devises subtle plans to achieve results in non-obvious ways. Subtlety of mind suggests perceiving or understanding deeply rather than superficially. It can also suggest a kind of untrustworthy cleverness—sneakiness. Perhaps the most famous use of the word "subtle" occurs in Genesis 3:1:

Now the serpent was more subtle than any beast of the field which the Lord God had made. And he said unto the woman, "Yea, hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree in the garden?"

The serpent is tricking Eve into eating the forbidden fruit, by subtle arguments and subtle manipulations. Other translations give a variety of words in place of "subtle": shrewd, clever, crafty, cunning, astute.

Discriminate

Discriminate comes from Latin roots meaning to make a difference or discern a difference between things. In its most primary sense in English, "discriminate" simply means to perceive a difference between things that are similar, enabling you to treat them differently. For example, this page talks about experiments with octopuses, in which they were found to be able to discriminate between mirror images, and could more easily discriminate between horizontally oriented figures than between diagonal ones. In mathematics and science, a discriminant is a factor that is relatively easy to calculate or measure, which enables you to sort similar things into separate groups, like the way in algebra the expression b2 – 4ac tells which kind of roots a polynomial has.

More commonly, though, people use the word "discriminate" to mean noticing relatively subtle differences between similar things, which make one thing better than another. For example:

Kushner decided to create a caffeine-free substitute that would taste so much like coffee, it would satisfy those with discriminating taste while still offering health benefits.

That is, some coffee drinkers are aware of and care about subtle differences in flavor: they have discriminating tastes. A discriminating coffee drinker would most likely be displeased with a decaffeinated coffee, because removing the caffeine also tends to alter the flavor. Calling someone discriminating in this sense is a compliment. Calling someone indiscriminate is pejorative: it suggests obliviousness to quality, subtlety, or refinement. A person who drinks coffee indiscriminately doesn't notice the fine differences in flavor between different varieties of coffee bean or methods of preparation.

In more recent times, at least in the United States, the word discriminate has taken on a new, narrower sense that now almost overpowers the others. This sense is: treating people differently in public matters such as hiring employees, serving customers, providing public transportation, or providing housing, on the basis of matters of group prejudice or group animus rather than on the basis of relevant matters such as qualification to do the job. When people speak of racial discrimination, this is what they have in mind. The Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title VI says:

No person in the United States shall, on the ground of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.

Many other public and private organizations have adopted similar wording for their own anti-discrimination policies.

Conclusion

Now that you've seen how "subtle" and "discriminating" are used in practice, you can form your own conclusion about whether they are synonyms. In my opinion, it would be misleading to call them synonyms, though there is a small overlap between a couple of their senses. Both have senses suggesting refined tastes or refined perception. But hopefully now it doesn't matter, because now you've got your understanding of the words grounded in widely known real usage more than in definitions.

  • In the KJB, that serpent is still subtile. – P. E. Dant Jul 19 '17 at 22:15
  • @P.E.Dant Or even subtil. Yeah, I used the modern spelling and added quotation marks. I figure there's plenty to digest here without going into alternate spellings, and I doubt that any of this is easy reading for an ESL learner. I also resisted the temptation to include the sense invoked by Kant in "The Mistaken Subtilty of the Four Syllogistic Figures" (though happily now I get to mention it in a comment). – Ben Kovitz Jul 19 '17 at 22:28
  • Yeah, that way lies madness. I think the OP's problem, though, is that she doesn't understand the function of a dictionary, and not that she doesn't understand just the two words in question. That's a meta problem (not in the sense of "belongs at the meta site"). – P. E. Dant Jul 19 '17 at 22:32
  • @P.E.Dant This answer tries to address that possibility, too, mostly by example. I think it's just a natural cognitive bias to attribute more precision, finality, and authority to dictionaries than they could possibly merit—for a while. Hopefully when people read a few explanations that trace the way contemporary senses of a word have branched out from a central sense, they might become cured. – Ben Kovitz Jul 20 '17 at 4:33
  • A good long read at Finnegan's Wake will superannuate the ol' dictionary in a trice. – P. E. Dant Jul 20 '17 at 4:43
1

The dictionary on my Mac uses both of those words (subtle and discriminating), but expounds on the meanings a little further and provides some examples:

refined (adj)
• elegant and cultured in appearance, manner, or taste: her voice was very low and refined.
• developed or improved so as to be precise or subtle: building up a more refined profile of the customer's needs.

The dictionary you cite looks like it's giving a "bare-bones" definition that in this case doesn't work all that well.

My rule of thumb? When one dictionary confuses me, I consult another. OneLook is an excellent place to start.

1

You remember “the Most Interesting Man In The World”?

A man like that is refined, in that he has excellent manners and conducts himself courteously.

He is subtle, in that his behavior is dignified and low-key.

He is discriminating, in that he can and does make fine distinctions about food, clothing, and people.

(A thing, a bottle of wine for example, might be subtle and refined, and would be appreciated by discriminating people; it cannot itself be discriminating.)

You can see these words are not perfect synonyms, but that they often go together.

Stay thirsty, my friend.

0

That which is subtle has nuances. It may take a discriminating person to perceive the nuances.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.