0

BBC\World:

A baby has been born from an embryo frozen for nearly 25 years - possibly the longest gap between conception and birth since IVF began. The embryo was donated by a family in the US and has become the first child for a woman who would herself have been only one when the baby was conceived.

The "would have been" constructions are used primarily to refer to unreal situations (mainly past events which cannot be undone or done otherwise): It would have been nice if he had thanked you. But here we've got a precisely defined occurrence, nothing uncertain about it. Why does the sentence not go then as a woman who herself was only one when the baby was conceived? What's the point of using "would have been" here?

1
1

It is used to point to the fact, that if the woman had conceived the baby herself, it would have been at the age of one, which is an unreal (and medically impossible) situation.

So, it is not used to talk about the real situation of her age at the time, when the baby was conceived, but about imagining how it would have been, if the woman had conceived the baby in the "normal" way.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.