1

I have the following sentence:

Successfully ran the "user.js" seed.

Is that "the" necessary?


When is it necessary and when is it not?

migrated from english.stackexchange.com Oct 3 at 23:14

This question came from our site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts.

  • 2
    It's necessary whenever you have a noun after the name. Observe: Successfully read War and Peace. Successfully watched Heat. Successfully ran user.js. But: Successfully read the War and Peace book. Successfully watched the Heat movie. Successfully ran the user.js seed. The "the" belongs to the noun after the name, and having the noun there but not having the "the" would be ungrammatical. But if you drop the noun, you drop the article, too. (Unless of course, there's a "the" in the name itself, like Successfully read The Observer, or Successfully watched The Fugitive.) – ЯegDwight Oct 3 at 23:14
  • Thanks! If you want to create an answer, I'll accept it. :) – Luiz Felipe Oct 3 at 23:40
0

In your example, the definite article is needed because you are being specific.

I successfully ran the "user.js" seed.

You ran a seed. Which seed? The "user.js" seed. If you can ask "which..." then there must be more than one and you need to be more specific, using the definite article.

If the article you are referring to has a unique name then there is no need for the definite article. Sticking with your computing scenario, consider this example:

Open Device Manager.

"Device Manager" is a proper noun for an extension of the Microsoft Management Console. There is only one Device Manager on your computer, so there is no need for the definite article. Nobody can rightly ask "which device manager?"

However, if you said:

Open the Device Manager console window.

Here, the definite article is required, because you are referring to its console window, and there are lots of console windows.

Open the console window. Which console window? The Device Manager console window.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.