0

I'm really confused about present and past tense usage, I'll provide some examples.

  1. He was the first one to complete the challenge

Why not is? Because right now, he's still in fact the first man to complete the challenge?

  1. I forget his name

Why not forgot...? Because in the past you forgot his name...It's like when we just completed something, we say 'we did it' not 'we do it'

3
  • 1
    These are just conventional usages, without any logical explanation. I suppose (1) looks back to the moment when the challenge was completed for the first time. For (2), we could also say "I have forgotten his name," but the present tense means "I don't have it readily accessible in my memory at this moment". – Kate Bunting Mar 21 at 9:10
  • Because it implies that every time this is mentioned, "i forget this name". – Lambie Mar 21 at 16:19
  • Hey Kate, if we say ‘I forget his name’ because I don’t remember his name at this moment, why can we say ‘I drive car’ when I’m driving..? – Jason Mar 21 at 23:28
0

I would say that in a sentence like this, the verb tense indicates the man’s presence.

“He is the first person to beat the challenge” means he beat the challenge, and now he’s still around. He might be right in the room at the time, or they might still have regular communication with him.

“He was the first person to beat the challenge” means he beat the challenge, but he’s gone now. Maybe he moved away, stopped communicating, or died.

The question of whether someone is still around or not is vague and depends on your interpretation of the situation. Since the distinction is so small, these phrases are sometimes used interchangeably, but it is better to use the appropriate tense for the man’s presence.

1
  • Ah, that makes sense. So let’s say, Donald Trump isn’t the president any more, we would say ‘he was the 45th present’ even though it’s a general fact that he is still the 45th president? – Jason Mar 21 at 23:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.