I have a question about this highlighted part of an ESL pod transcript:

Mandy: Whoo! Whoo!  Theo: Hey, get down from there. You shouldn’t be sticking your head out of the sunroof.  Mandy: I just wanted to get some air. This stretch limo is amazing.  Theo: Well, I thought I’d rent one and take you to the prom in style.
Mandy: This is the height of luxury. You’ve really outdone yourself.  Theo: Thanks, but maybe we should be careful not to spill drinks on the seats.   Mandy: Everybody drinks and parties in the back of a limo. Why else would they have a wet bar?  Theo: Well, we shouldn’t be drinking out of it. We could get into trouble.  Mandy: The chauffeur doesn’t know what we’re doing back here.

Does ** why + else + would has a grammar usage? And what does this question mean? As it is very difficult to understand could you please provide me with some more examples?

  • Does it have the same meaning with otherwise? – Zhang Sep 25 '18 at 8:29

"Why else" is a common construction in conversational English, meaning, "for what other reason". Read that sentence as "For what other reason would they have a wet bar?" This is a rhetorical question, i.e. a question that has only one possible answer, used to prove a point. There is a wet bar in the limo, so if it's not to provide drinks, what other purpose could it have? One could say this is rhetorical use of Occam's razor; Mandy uses it in a cutting manner.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.