3

What's the difference between a rubber/inflatable boat, a rubber/inflatable dinghy and a rubber/inflatable raft appearance-wise? What visual clues do native English speakers look out for to pinpoint which word should be used?

They both look they same and purpose-wise, they overlap. I cannot tease out the difference between them.

Can you perhaps tell me if there are any visual clues based on which native speakers determine when to use which? (Maybe I have overlooked them)

Thank you in advance!

Improve this question
7

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
0

The first point is the noun:

Among the types of craft that can go in the water for people to use are: a raft, a dinghy, a boat.

So, a raft is today is usually a flat craft made of rubber or wood or plastic or bamboo or some type of wood.

So, one for playing or just floating in the water will be like this and is inflatable and made of plastic . That is what makes it float:

  1. a plastic raft for pool or lake/ocean an inflatable raft for playing in the water made of plastic

  2. a bamboo raft A raft from the Green Trails company

  3. a log raft
    a log raft from the backpacker.com

All of those are: Merriam Webster
: a flat structure (as of wood) for support or transportation on water

So the semantic trait for a raft is: flat structure, floatable, used for support or transportation

  1. But there are also rafts made of rubber for whitewater rafting that look like this:

inflatable rubber raft

[These types of raft are always made of rubber and are inflatable.]

So, now we add a semantic trait: flat, inflatable sides/ends, rubber

  1. A dinghy is a craft with sides and looks like a rowboat:

a typical dinghy on the left

Dinghies are often towed behind a sailboat as an emergency craft and may have an outboard motor but are also used for all sorts of recreation purposes themselves like fishing and are even sometimes equipped with a sail. They can also be rowed:

sailing dinghy

Boats: generally, boats per se are not inflatable EXCEPT for the Zodiacs, used by regular people for recreational purposes and also by the armed forces. They are made of rubber and their pontoons (the "tubes") are filled with air.

See the range of inflatable Zodiac boats here: ZodiaC

Here is a typical one:

from Pacific Portable Boats

A dinghy can be made of aluminum, plastic or wood.

To summarize: a raft is not a boat as it is too specific to be one. A dinghy is a type of small boat and has sides. Some of them that are really Zodiacs (with poontoons) can be inflatable. The aluminum dinghies are not inflatable.

Recreational rafts are inflatable and made of plastic or rubber. Other types (wooden or log raft) are not.

Dinghies are wood, rubber, or aluminum. The rubber ones are inflatable and generally associated with a Zodiac or Zodiac-type craft.

Dinghies are small boats. Rafts are not boats but they are a water craft.

Visual clues for a raft: flatness on the water and Generally, no sides though some have them.

This nomenclature is NOT AmE. It's just English.

Improve this answer
8
  • See, I would argue that a boat is, well, as MW says, "a small vessel for travel on water." That is, if it floats and you can get in it and you can reasonably get from place to place, it's a boat. Thus a pool float isn't a boat (usually/arguably), but a coracle, a bamboo raft, a rubber whitewater rafting raft, and a lifeboat all are. Meanwhile from reading Patrick O'Brian I know that ships hate being called boats, and may draw distinctions about how many masts and so forth. But for general purposes, "small" is enough to distinguish boat from ship.
    – Andy Bonner
    Commented Nov 13 at 16:20
  • 1
    One reasonable distinction I've seen for rafts vs. boats is how they derive their buoyancy - boats usually have a denser-than-water solid hull that excludes water and which would sink if filled, while rafts are usually made of material that's positively buoyant in the first place, like bamboo or inflatable tubing. A raft may or may not have sides, but doesn't require them to stay afloat, unlike a boat.
    – Nuclear Hoagie
    Commented Nov 13 at 16:32
  • @NuclearHoagie The semantic traits are different. That's enough.
    – Lambie
    Commented Nov 13 at 16:54
  • @AndyBonner I'm not writing a treatise, just the basic ideas. I myself could write an entire book and find all kinds of exceptions. The point is a raft is not a boat, a dinghy is a small boat and I won't define boat as we presumably all know what a boat is.
    – Lambie
    Commented Nov 13 at 16:56
  • I know that a raft can be made of wood and that a boat can be made of various materials! But I'd like to specifically focus the difference between inflatable/ rubber boats, dinghies and rafts made of rubber (as the name implies)
    – Idk29
    Commented Nov 13 at 20:15

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .