1

Which is the correct preposition to use here ?

The actual sentence which I read was

Your daughter has the best complexion of any girl in the college.

But the part after complexion sounds a little weird, using than here sounds better but going by grammar rules than is used mostly with comparative degree and since here we have superlative degree (best) of should come. So is of correct here ?

  • than would be incorrect. best than is ungrammatical. best of is correct. – Tᴚoɯɐuo Jun 15 '17 at 13:46
  • @Tᴚoɯɐuo Yes that's what I mentioned in post that going by rules 'than' is wrong with best. So 'of' is correct here ? – user212388 Jun 15 '17 at 13:48
1

As a quick preface to what might be an unnecessary answer, I'd like to just add as a note, I do not believe "...the best complexion of any..." is actually correct English (though I'm not 100% certain). You are more likely to hear "...the best complexion of all..." or "...a better complexion than any..." The word "any" implies that you are making one-to-one comparisons and I do not think it is appropriate to use a superlative with it. Nevertheless, despite my concerns with the provided sentence, using "than" is categorically incorrect.

English has two degrees of comparison: "Comparative" and "Superlative" (note they are not usually capitalized but I'm doing that to draw a distinction between the Comparative form and comparison in general).

The Comparative form is used when making comparison between two things.

English is easier than Japanese.

9 is a more interesting number than 8.

"Easier" and "more interesting" are the comparative forms of "easy" and "interesting" and they are used to compare two things: "English" and "Japanese" in the first example and "9" and "8" in the second.

Comparative adjectives use the word "than" to qualify the comparison.

The Superlative form is usually used making a comparison between one thing to an entire group.

English is the easiest of all languages.

9 is the most interesting number of them all.

"Easiest" and "most interesting" are the superlatives forms of the above mentioned adjectives and they are used to compare "English" and "9" to "all languages (of which English is one)" and "them (numbers) all (of which "9" is one)"

Superlative adjectives use the word "of" to qualify the comparison.

Comparative sentences feel like you are ordering two things. Superlative sentences feel like you are selecting one thing from a group. Thus it is reasonable to use "than" with comparatives (since "than" gives a feeling of sequence or order) and "of" with superlatives (since "of" or perhaps more correctly "out of" can establish a group).

  • Yes correct! That's what I too had mentioned in the post that we use 'of' with superlative degree but unlike your answer that was a terse statement, I appreciate your writing such a long answer but except your 1st paragraph rest answer wasn't relevant here as I had already mentioned in question that I know this grammar rule but anyway your 1st paragraph cleared my doubt, I mentioned that to my ears the part after complexion was sounding weird, its because I need to use all in place of any in the sentence, – user212388 Jun 15 '17 at 14:13
  • so the correct sentence is - Your daughter has the best complexion of all girls in the college – user212388 Jun 15 '17 at 14:13
  • yes it is. ........ – G-Cam Jun 15 '17 at 14:27
  • "Best complexion of all the girls", but "better complexion than any girl" – Philip Roe Jun 24 '17 at 20:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.