1

Despite the huge death toll, more than 200,000 Hungarian Jews survived the war, a number inconceivable had Horthy not secured relative independence for his country for so long. (The Telegraph)

‘A number inconceivable’ seems to be a supplementive unit related to ‘more than 200,000,’ on the other hand there seems to be omitted its subject and verb because of the following subjunctive sentence. How do I look at this sentence?

2 Answers 2

3

The only unconventional matter here is the manner in which your bolded phrase and what follows are attached to the preceding sentence: by simple juxtaposition, with no conjunction or other transitional device. There is probably a technical name for it somewhere in Classical Rhetoric (asyndeton, perhaps?), but I would just call it a “Comment”.

Usually such comments are much simpler:

More than 200,000 Hungarian Jews survived the war—an inconceivable number!

in this case, however, the comment is raised only to be immediately qualified. This is achieved by “recategorizing” it as the main or consequence clause of a conditional (IF...THEN) construction, as if it originally read

[This] number [would be] inconceivable had Horthy not &c   OR
[This would be] an inconceivable number had Horthy not &c

In effect it is exactly as you say: the verb is “omitted” (and possibly the subject, too). Except of course it was (they were) never actually there, so I think it would be better to say that it is (or they are) “implicit”.

In any case, the usual inconceivable number is inverted because the author is uncommonly careful to make his qualification (had Horthy not &c) apply only to inconceivable and not to number as well.

2

“Number” in that sentence refers specifically to 200,000, which appeared earlier in the sentence. There are no structural problems with the sentence; it is nearly equivalent in meaning to the following:

Despite the huge death toll, more than 200,000 Hungarian Jews survived the war. It is inconceivable so many would have survived if Horthy had not secured relative independence for his country for so long.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .