0

For me it's easier beccause since I have been doing music I have always sung in french

in that case I have always sang seems a continuously and ongoing action which has not stopped yet. Why not I have been singing to convey this idea of this ongoing continuity Is it because have been singing means that he is always singing 24 hours a day or is it because the present perfect progressive is used before

1
  • of course , sorry for this mistake
    – user5577
    Oct 14, 2018 at 4:58

1 Answer 1

0

The "facts on the ground" do not force us to use one expression or another. What we say expresses our view of the facts.

Both forms of the present perfect make a statement about the world up until now.

You could use have been singing:

I have been singing in French ever since I began taking singing lessons.

to emphasize that at no time did you abandon that practice since first taking it up. It began back then and has continued.

Few native speakers would take that to mean that you have never stopped singing, not even for meals or sleep, but a comedian like Groucho Marx might ask "So how do you sleep?"

You can also use have sung

I have sung in French ever since I began taking singing lessons.

to indicate that on those occasions when you sang, it was in French, and this has been true since you began taking lessons. Groucho would not be able to make the same quip there.

2
  • So both tenses are ok in this case .May be as the authour choose always he preferred the present perfect simple because always indicates the continuity of ongoing action
    – user5577
    Oct 14, 2018 at 12:34
  • Yes, the word always reinforces the idea, and it could be used with either the simple or the continuous. Oct 14, 2018 at 12:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .