0

Let's say my friend is watching a movie on tv in his room, I walk into the room, watch a few scenes of the movie and ask

Is it supposed to be a comedy movie?

How is the expression different from the expression

Is it a comedy movie?

Does the first expression mean the same thing as second? Or does it have a negative tone like "is it supposed to be comedy a movie, because it does not feel like one"?

1

Yes.

In this particular sentence, asking if a movie is "supposed to be" a comedy implies that it doesn't appear to be a comedy. Presumably, it isn't funny.

It's common to use "supposed to be" more literally to refer to a desired condition, as opposed to an actual condition. Like, "What is the oil pressure in this machine supposed to be?" I may be observing a reading of the actual oil pressure, and I want to know if that is the correct oil pressure. Depending on tone, context, etc, I may be implying that I think that it is not the desired value, or it may be a straightforward question asking for information.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.