0

my own examples:
(1) No idea of what we will do occured to me. — I think it's correct.
(2) No idea what we will do occured to me. — I think it's incorrect.
That is, "of" is obligatory.

britannica.com:
(3) I have no idea what you're talking about. — I would have thought it was not correct without a preposition but the dictionary says it is.
As far as I understand, the fact that there isn't a preposition between a noun and an interrogative content clause violates the English grammar.
What makes (3) an exclusion to the rules?
What does the interrogative content clause "what you're talking about" in (3) function as?

my variant:
(4) I have no idea of what you're talking about. — I think it's correct and fits the normal grammar rules.
The interrogative content clause "what you're talking about" functions as the complement of the preposition "of".
The prepositional phrase "of what you're talking about" functions as the modifier to the noun "idea".

15
  • Have you researched the topic of ellipsis (the omission of common words, not the three dots like this...)? Commented Feb 29 at 9:11
  • (1) isn't correct. The sentence refers to a moment in the past, so it should be "No idea of what we would do occurred to me" or, better still, "...of what to do". Commented Feb 29 at 10:04
  • @KateBunting "No idea of what we will do occured to me." — I wrote "will" to show the moment in future when we will do something hasn't come yet. Why is such an explanation of using "will" incorrect here? Thanks.
    – Loviii
    Commented Feb 29 at 10:22
  • There are some constructions where the preposition is optional, as it is in your example: "I have no idea (of) what you're talking about". Thus, the content clause may be complement of the preposition "of" or directly of the noun "idea".
    – BillJ
    Commented Feb 29 at 10:31
  • I understood the sentence to be part of a narrative about the past. If you are talking about the present moment, it would have to be "occurs to me" - but that's a very convoluted way of saying "I have no idea what to do." Commented Feb 29 at 10:50

0

You must log in to answer this question.