1

Here's the context.

John saw a girl dancing in a bar 3 days ago.

Jihoon saw a girl studying in the library yesterday.

The two girls are the same girl.

In this situation,

  1. The girl John saw dancing in a bar 3 days ago is the same person as/that Jihoon saw studying in the library yesterday.

  2. Jihoon saw the same girl studying in the library as/that John saw dancing in a bar.

  3. John saw a girl dancing in a bar 3 days ago and the girl is the same person that Jihoon saw studying in the library yesterday.

I've made 3 sentences to understand how to use 'the same~' sentence structure. And I think these are all possible to use and the same meaning. Or is there any difference in meaning? And I think as/that are all possible here, but I do agree that there are some people who stick to using only one of them

  • english.stackexchange.com/questions/36789/… This might help you. – Nicholas J. Jul 31 '15 at 4:22
  • "Yesterday, Jihoon saw a girl studying in the library, the same girl whom John saw dancing in a bar 3 days ago!" – Maulik V Jul 31 '15 at 5:11
  • 2
    For sentence one, it's not "as" or "that". The most complete form would be "as the one that Jihoon saw [. . .}" actually... it sounds better with nothing... "... same person Jihoon saw studying..." – Catija Jul 31 '15 at 5:43
  • At a first glance I thought that Jihoon and John were the same person and it was just a spelling mistake. Use visually different names, it'll be easier :) – laureapresa Jul 31 '15 at 9:57
3

In this instance, use "that".

"As" would require an additional phrase:

Jihoon saw the same girl [studying in the library] as the one (that) John saw dancing in a bar.

You can see why this is when you take out the phrase studying in the library and even the word "girl". (i.e. You get a basic same as [x] construction.)

Examples:

  1. That car is the same as Bob's.

  2. That is the same car that Bob has.

Simply put, ...same as... is a comparison.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.